Stick fighting

Nightwing
Daredevil
Night Thrasher (classic NW version)
Moon Knight

Escrima sticks, billy clubs, truncheons as applicable

1. No other gear, just these weapons, work out clothes, in dojo

2. Full gear, abandoned warehouse

Both fights are no prior knowledge of opponents, win by KO

Daredevil, I feel. Especially with some of the trick shots he's pulled off.

Both scenarios?
I was going to say his lack of gear'd be a detriment in the second, until, duh, i remembered his senses would give him a huge advantage there.