Citizen Steel vs Superman

Speed is equalized. Pure h2h fight. DCnU

Citizen Steel is basically Colossus +, and that simply not enough to take down SM.

You failed at making a poll. Instead of mutually exclusive selections, you allow for multiple selections. Totally invalidating the whole purpose of this poll.

Oh and Superman by orders of magnitude.

This is pre FP CS
Same one who took down Gog the team wrecker

Also please STFU

Bump

Wow, i literally just re read CS's origin in JSA about 2 hours ago.

All things considered, i think Superman's the better HtH fighter, though if CS connects with a Good punch, he has enough power yo get the KO.
Thats a Long shot though.

Superman

Steel.

The vote results are interesting...

I'm not surprised Supess is in the lead considering this board

Oh, neither am i. I'm pleasantly surprised CS got any votes at all, though.
Granted, i give Supes the win but, i'd like to think i did so with an actual reason other than "Superman wins".

In this tier, Citizen steel is above Superman.

http://www.comicvine.com/profile/van_cere/lists/dc-tiers-list-finished/53871/

I don't know much about Citizen steel, but Is he really stronger than Superman?
What do you think?

Originally posted by CatL18
In this tier, Citizen steel is above Superman.

http://www.comicvine.com/profile/van_cere/lists/dc-tiers-list-finished/53871/

I don't know much about Citizen steel, but Is he really stronger than Superman?
What do you think?

Stronger? Possibly. He was shown to have more effect on Gog than earth 22 Superman.
More durable? Probably not.
Also not as well trained s fighter IMO, which is why i give Supes the win.

This thread lasts long enough there will be all sorts of canon/non canon arguments thrown out to help Superman save face and re-re-re-re establish his overwhelming superiority in all things, but at its simplest its:

CS stronger possibly

CS not as durable

CS not the better fighter

Originally posted by riv6672
This thread lasts long enough there will be all sorts of canon/non canon arguments thrown out to help Superman save face and re-re-re-re establish his overwhelming superiority in all things, but at its simplest its:

CS stronger possibly

CS not as durable

CS not the better fighter

Originally posted by CatL18
Thanks.
So, is Superman more versataile than CS?

Have a think about it.

What powers does Steel have?

What powers does Superman have?

Yeah, versatility's a given for Supes.

Originally posted by riv6672
Stronger? Possibly. He was shown to have more effect on Gog than earth 22 Superman.
More durable? Probably not.
Also not as well trained s fighter IMO, which is why i give Supes the win.

This thread lasts long enough there will be all sorts of canon/non canon arguments thrown out to help Superman save face and re-re-re-re establish his overwhelming superiority in all things, but at its simplest its:

CS stronger possibly

CS not as durable

CS not the better fighter

And FYI, the Gog who battled JSA was the same Gog who fought Superman.

Specified in the very same JSA comic.

I think you're mixing up your Gogs, or i am. Or the internet is.
Citizen Steel used his full strength on a giant. Magog, then.

JSA 22. Just skimmed it. The giant was called Gog. Went down like a ton of bricks.

Didnt STAY down, but still...🙂

That was third world Gog. The Gog Steel fought was his herald who True Gog incinerated in JSA 18 and created Magog.

Read the comics first.