Nightwing & Red Hood vs. Black Widow & Punisher

Who wins?

Grayson and Todd take this

Nightwing and Todd easily, team 2 doesn't have the feats to contend here.

Jason and Dick tire themselves out trying to beat Punisher to death.

Widow comes in for the easy kill.

Even though Punisher has a good damage soak, Nightwing could hit him with a pressure point and take him out instantly if he wanted to.

Team Batman Inc.

Team 1 shitstomps.

Nightwing and Red hood outclass BW and Frank in almost every way possible

how does Punisher have good damage soak when Bruce Wayne punched him out in both their encounters?

Team 1. I think people are underselling BW and Punisher in calling it a stomp, though. I think team 1 would win every time...but I think they'd have to work for it every single time.