Yoda, Windu and Dooku vs Sidious, Plagueis and Maul

Place: Palpatine's Office

Scenario 1: ROTS Yoda, Mace, Dooku and Sidious, TPM Plagueis and SoD Maul.
Scenario 2: Yoda's team get TPM Jinn

Scenario 1: Jedi win 6/10
Scenario 2: Jedi win 8/10

I was wondering if Jinn will be a facot here. Wont he be speedblitzed by Sidious? Will Yoda's presence prevent that?

Sidious vs Yoda = stalemate
Windu vs Plagueis = Windu
Dooku & Jinn vs Maul = Dooku and Jinn.

They just gang up on Sidious and that is that.

Interesting... But I'm not sure that Yoda can take Sidious by himself, and that may be the game changing factor in a fight this close.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Interesting... But I'm not sure that Yoda can take Sidious by himself, and that may be the game changing factor in a fight this close.

I'm sorry, what? Yoda disarmed Sidious and had him on the run for half of that fight. There's a reason Palpatine retreated into the Grand Convocation Chamber. In a place like Palpatine's office, Yoda has the advantage.

Yoda can defeat Sidious in this scenario but it won't come to that.

The question is if Mace can hold off Plagueis long enough for Dooku to kill Maul. And the answer to that is yes.

Team 1 in both scenarios.

Originally posted by Lord Stark

The question is if Mace can hold off Plagueis long enough for Dooku to kill Maul. And the answer to that is yes.

So you don't believe Jeremy Barlow ?

http://i1273.photobucket.com/albums/y418/karasakal_teach/EkranAl1310nt1310s1310_zpsa5b5c52e.png

TCW Maul can beat Dooku 7 of 10.

You're such a loser, lol.

Originally posted by Nephthys
You're such a loser, lol.

Shut up and just accept your defeat. 😮‍💨

lmfao. Higher canon sources state different.

Ironically enough it's the same source.

Nah. I remember Jack having some other sources on SWF.

In-universe statements though. From Dooku.

Wasn't there one also from the insider that had Dooku vs Maul?

TPM Maul tho

Originally posted by AncientPower
Scenario 1: Jedi win 6/10
Scenario 2: Jedi win 8/10

Yoda vs. Palpatine
The two stalemate in practically all categories

Mace vs. Plagueis
Edge in sabers: Mace, edge in the force: Plagueis, all-out: Mace should take slight majority, perhaps.

Dooku vs. Maul
Edge in sabers: Dooku, edge in the force: Dooku, all-out: Maul is reasonably close, but Dooku is just a bit better

Team 1 wins.

Originally posted by Marco1907
So you don't believe Jeremy Barlow ?

http://i1273.photobucket.com/albums/y418/karasakal_teach/EkranAl1310nt1310s1310_zpsa5b5c52e.png

TCW Maul can beat Dooku 7 of 10.

Not at all. He wasn't even involved with the Son of Dathomir project...or TCWs.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
In-universe statements though. From Dooku.

Which are worth a hell of a lot more than some dudes non-canon opinion.

I can see it as very close match up:
Sidious and Yoda are strongest.
Plagueis is between them, and Dooku and Windu.
Maul is the weakest.

I would say that:

Yoda > Sidious in sabers
Yoda = Sidious in the Force
Yoda >= Sidious in all-out

Windu / Dooku > Plagueis and Maul in sabers
Plagueis > Dooku >= Windu >= Maul in the Force
Plagueis > Dooku/Windu > Maul in all out