Windu, Plagueis and Exar Kun vs. HoT, Bane and Malgus

Started by Stigma1 pagesPoll

Which team is superior?

Windu, Plagueis and Exar Kun vs. HoT, Bane and Malgus

All combatants at their peak.
Setting: Jedi Praxeum on Yavin 4

1. Sabers
2. Force
3. All-out

Team 1, tempted to say they dominate.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Team 1, tempted to say they dominate.

👆

Kun > Malgus/Bane, Plagueis > Bane/Malgus, Windu > Bane/Malgus.

This is actually a great battle. It would be foolish to underestimate Team 2.

HoT is apparently the most powerful Jedi (Master) witnessed in a span of thousands of years of existence of the Jedi Order.

Malgus, at the height of his power, competed for the throne of the Emperor and held the throne for a while. A Sith Lord who is powerful enough to seize mantle of Emperor in times of great competition among Sith is logically a TOP-TIER individual among Sith in history.

Bane, at the height of his power, is assumed to be Orbalisks incarnation. And he is virtually immune to lightsaber stabs in this condition.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Team 1, tempted to say they dominate.

I lol'd.

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
I lol'd.

Exactly

Team 2 is very strong and have a good chance at winning.

Team 2 wins.
Hero>Mace.
Bane>Plagueis.
Malgus>Kun.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Team 1, tempted to say they dominate.

Yeah, seems about right.

Well, it's not like it's Bane's fault he's outmached here... Besides, I gave him powerful teammates to compensate 😛

I actually did not consider the possibility of Bane being armed with Orbalisk Armor. :mmm: Team 1 still wins.

Mace should be able to go toe to toe with Bane via Vaapad whilst the other matches play out.

Plagueis>Malgus, and Exar>Hero, especially on Yavin IV.

I never saw Kun was on Yavin. :mmm:

You guys have Malgus above Kun? Team 1 should win solidly, honestly.

Originally posted by Trocity
You guys have Malgus above Kun? Team 1 should win solidly, honestly.

Only *some* people, I believe.

Also, I'm curious where do people rank HoT in this fight. Can he take majority against Windu, Kun... Plagueis?

I feel that there's a lack of information thus far about the HoT to suggest getting a majority or drawing against top tiers like Kun and Plagueis. While I personally feel she rivals those heights in power and skill, I'd be hard pressed to seriously defend that position. She might beat Kun in a duel though.

However, isn't the Jedi Praxeum on Yavin a potent force nexus such that it let Dorsk 82 shove 17 Star Destroyers? If the Hero can tap into that kind if energy, she can stand a very good chance against them.

None of the above, honestly, especially on Yavin IV.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
I actually did not consider the possibility of Bane being armed with Orbalisk Armor. :mmm: Team 1 still wins.

Mace should be able to go toe to toe with Bane via Vaapad whilst the other matches play out.

Plagueis>Malgus, and Exar>Hero, especially on Yavin IV.

Pretty much this.

Originally posted by Nephthys
I feel that there's a lack of information thus far about the HoT to suggest getting a majority or drawing against top tiers like Kun and Plagueis. While I personally feel she rivals those heights in power and skill, I'd be hard pressed to seriously defend that position. She might beat Kun in a duel though.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
None of the above, honestly, especially on Yavin IV.

I see.

My personal guess would be that HoT is in the same tier as, say, Windu/Dooku, but slightly less powerful and with a less skill with a saber. But this is pretty much arbitrary position.

Originally posted by Nephthys
However, isn't the Jedi Praxeum on Yavin a potent force nexus such that it let Dorsk 82 shove 17 Star Destroyers? If the Hero can tap into that kind if energy, she can stand a very good chance against them.

Yes, it is. To what extend it will benefit the combatants is a good question.

Windu >> Anyone on team 2.
Kun > Anyone on team 2.
Plagueis >>> Anyone on team 2.

My personal guess would be that HoT is in the same tier as, say, Windu/Dooku, but slightly less powerful and with a less skill with a saber. But this is pretty much arbitrary position.

Fair assessment, though I'd say the Hero is just as "powerful" as someone like Dooku, likely even moreso, but he's not nearly as developed as a Force user.

But yeah, he's basically the physical equal of those two, and closely approaches their skill as well.

Bane is out of his depth here.

Team 1 destroys.