Jaina Solo vs. ROTJ Darth Vader

Started by carthage2 pages
carthage PLEASE PROTECT ME STONES

Jaina Solo vs. ROTJ Darth Vader

Force, sabers, all out

Sinious Yo Da Best

Darth Vader wins imo. I'm still surprised that there are people who place her above Vader.

Marco1907 Great Sith Lord

Vader takes this.

Arhael Devoid of reality

Jaina. 🙂

ares834 Senior Member

Good fight. Vader takes it.

Nephthys The Gr8est!!!!!!!!

Vader

AncientPower The Chosen One

Jaina wins, Caedus is certainly superior to Vader in every single possible way.

Jaina didn't take him in a total 1 vs 1 but she did show that in a duel she can very much hold her own against him.

Holding her own against Caedus definitely puts her on Vader tier.

Arhael Devoid of reality

She did take him completely 1x1 in the end of the book though

NewGuy01 perpetual

While this is true, she did have the advantage of him being armless and stabbed in the gut, and tbh was still being overwhelmed.

FreshestSlice Eternal Commander

Vader.

Arhael Devoid of reality

Originally posted by NewGuy01
While this is true, she did have the advantage of him being armless and stabbed in the gut, and tbh was still being overwhelmed.

Not having an arm is a minor disadvantage, one-handed fencing can be just as effective as two-handed. That stubbing in the gut did not hamper him in any way and on opposite it made him stronger, he immediately responded with powerful TK punch that badly concussed Jaina.

NewGuy01 perpetual

Jacen disagrees with you.

WollfMyth Member

Jaina wins. Vader is just as skilled, if not more so, and his power is beyond Jaina's.

Sinious Yo Da Best
Originally posted by WollfMyth
Jaina wins. Vader is just as skilled, if not more so, and his power is beyond Jaina's.

And thats why Jaina wins?

ILS Restricted

LMFAO @ having a missing arm and being stabbed through the gut being a "minor disadvantage". The character wanking in Star Wars debate never ceases to amaze me. With a bit of bad grammar this could be reaching Marco levels...

Emperordmb LSDMB

Yeah, not to mention the fact that Jacen still could've easily gotten a stalemate there.

Trocity Undefeated and Undisputed

The reason I have Jaina above Vader is because I don't have Caedus below ROTS Sidious by a big margin. The fact that she can do so well against him, regardless of his injuries, impresses me greatly.

Vorpal Ruin Jedi Master
Originally posted by Sinious
Darth Vader wins imo. I'm still surprised that there are people who place her above Vader.

Jaina wins imo. I'm still surprised people underestimate Jaina so often around here.

Q99 Senior Member
Originally posted by ILS
LMFAO @ having a missing arm and being stabbed through the gut being a "minor disadvantage".

The arm was somewhat, but notably Jacen was specifically not slowed or hindered by pain, he had techniques to ignore it completely.

I mean, they certainly play a role in why she *won* (with the best he could hope for being a draw) rather than him winning, but it wasn't the size of disadvantage it'd be for many.

DarthAnt66 DarthAnt66
Originally posted by Arhael
Not having an arm is a minor disadvantage.