Manhatten wins, hulk has no way of hurting him.
May i refer all of you to these thread:
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles-7/dr-manhattan-vs-hulk-405286/
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles-7/hulk-vs-drmanhattan-671611/
Manhatten wins, hulk has no way of hurting him.
May i refer all of you to these thread:
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles-7/dr-manhattan-vs-hulk-405286/
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles-7/hulk-vs-drmanhattan-671611/
Originally posted by thingy150Dude, please stop using Comicvine, no one like that place.
Manhatten wins, hulk has no way of hurting him.May i refer all of you to these thread:
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles-7/dr-manhattan-vs-hulk-405286/
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles-7/hulk-vs-drmanhattan-671611/
Originally posted by thingy150
Manhatten wins, hulk has no way of hurting him.May i refer all of you to these thread:
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles-7/dr-manhattan-vs-hulk-405286/
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles-7/hulk-vs-drmanhattan-671611/
You complained about people posting links to Thor's respect thread, or telling you to go there, instead of giving examples, in your Orion vs Thor topic. Now you're essentially doing the same here.
I've never read the comic but if comic Manhattan is superior to the movie version (and honestly, most comic versions of characters are) then I don't see any reason why Manhattan wouldn't stomp 10/10... and why do you say Manhattan is "overrated", Delta? How could a character like him possibly be overrated? Seriously, going by just what I've seen from the movie, I think he would wreck just about any comic book character including the big "S" himself and I'm one of the biggest Superman fans in the world.
Originally posted by Star428
I've never read the comic but if comic Manhattan is superior to the movie version (and honestly, most comic versions of characters are) then I don't see any reason why Manhattan wouldn't stomp 10/10... and why is Manhattan "overrated", delta? Seriously, going by just what I've seen from the movie, I think he would wreck just about any comic book character including the big "S" himself and I'm one of the biggest Superman fans in the world.
It's because all he did was against weaksauce guys.
Originally posted by Delta1938
vin 😂 😆
I don't usually agree with DarkSaint but why couldn't Manhattan do this? If it's so ridiculously funny as you make it seem for Manhattan to be able to do something like that then the comic version must really suck compared to the movie version because I saw him do stuff like that in the movie.
Edit: Nevermind. I see that you said he would likely do something like that in an earlier post.
Originally posted by Star428
I've never read the comic but if comic Manhattan is superior to the movie version (and honestly, most comic versions of characters are) then I don't see any reason why Manhattan wouldn't stomp 10/10... and why do you say Manhattan is "overrated", Delta? How could a character like him possibly be overrated? Seriously, going by just what I've seen from the movie, I think he would wreck just about any comic book character including the big "S" himself and I'm one of the biggest Superman fans in the world.
Like I said, I haven't read BEFORE WATCHMEN yet, and apparently he's actually done stuff that's impressive. But people were making claims of him being omnipotent long before they published BEFORE WATCHMEN.
The most impressive thing he did in WATCHMEN was teleport the distance between Earth and Mars. People assume he can disintegrate anybody just because he disintegrated a normal human. They assume because he can manipulate matter, he can turn anybody into a teapot or a pink bunny, even if a character has shown to resist transmutation.
They basically dickride him with the No Limits Fallacy despite it's all a bunch of unsubstantiated hype and assumption. He seemed omnipotent to the Average Joe in WATCHMEN, but he was a medium sized fish in a tiny pond when compared to better established comic universes.
Originally posted by Delta1938
Like I said, I haven't read BEFORE WATCHMEN yet, and apparently he's actually done stuff that's impressive. But people were making claims of him being omnipotent long before they published BEFORE WATCHMEN.The most impressive thing he did in WATCHMEN was teleport the distance between Earth and Mars. People assume he can disintegrate anybody just because he disintegrated a normal human. They assume because he can manipulate matter, he can turn anybody into a teapot or a pink bunny, even if a character has shown to resist transmutation.
They basically dickride him with the No Limits Fallacy despite it's all a bunch of unsubstantiated hype and assumption. He seemed omnipotent to the Average Joe in WATCHMEN, but he was a medium sized fish in a tiny pond when compared to better established comic universes.
Ok. I get it now. Just to be clear, I'm not "dickriding" him though. LOL. I play on the other team if you know what I mean... He just seemed stupid powerful in the movie but you do have a point I guess that he's never done any kind of transmutation on beings other than humans. It might not work on characters like Hulk or Superman. But then it might afterall. We really don't know one way or the other because he's never tried it on a meta in the comics, correct?
Originally posted by Star428
Ok. I get it now. Just to be clear, I'm not "dickriding" him though. LOL. He just seemed stupid powerful in the movie but you do have a point I guess that he's never done any kind of transmutation on beings other than humans. It might not work on characters like Hulk or Superman. But then it might afterall. We really don't know one way or the other because he's never tried it on a meta in the comics, correct?
Exactly.
I mean, where would it end?
Dr. M vs Daredevil
Dr. M vs Doom
Dr. M vs Odin
Dr. M vs Living Tribunal
etc....
Originally posted by Star428
Ok. I get it now. Just to be clear, I'm not "dickriding" him though. LOL. I play on the other team if you know what I mean... He just seemed stupid powerful in the movie but you do have a point I guess that he's never done any kind of transmutation on beings other than humans. It might not work on characters like Hulk or Superman. But then it might afterall. We really don't know one way or the other because he's never tried it on a meta in the comics, correct?
😱 😄 😆 Pretty sure you know "dickriding" in this context isn't literal. vin
Saying "we don't know" is a bit too speculative. Of course we don't know, but there's only so far you can legitimately take speculation and it not be wishful thinking.
Originally posted by Delta1938
Saying "we don't know" is a bit too speculative. Of course we don't know, but there's only so far you can legitimately take speculation and it not be wishful thinking.
Wishful thinking? I honestly have no attachment to the character of Manhattan. He's nothing to me. It's not like he's one of my favorite characters or anything and I don't really hate or even dislike Hulk either so I really don't care who would win this fight. I always give my honest opinion of who I think would win a fight based on what I've seen, read, or heard about the characters. I never base it on which character I like more.
You're smilies, btw, are almost as cute as those cat photos you posted for Thanksgiving. 🙂
Originally posted by Star428
Wishful thinking? I honestly have no attachment to the character of Manhattan. He's nothing to me. It's not like he's one of my favorite characters or anything and I don't really hate or even dislike Hulk either so I really don't care who would win this fight. I always give my honest opinion of who I think would win a fight based on what I've seen, read, or heard about the characters. I never base it on which character I like more.You're smilies, btw, are almost as cute as those cat photos you posted for Thanksgiving. 🙂
I was talking more about speculation of "well we don't really know for sure, do we?" in general than you specifically. DS said it well here.
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Exactly.I mean, where would it end?
Dr. M vs Daredevil
Dr. M vs Doom
Dr. M vs Odin
Dr. M vs Living Tribunaletc....
I literally came across a blog where someone put a list of a whole bunch of characters, with the usual suspects like Hulk, Superman, Doctor Strange, but including Galactus and Mxy, and said Manhattan wins all but Mxy. And he didn't give Mxy the win, he just said it's undetermined due to not knowing how Manhattan could effect 5th dimensional space.