DCnu Wonder Woman slug fest Gauntlet

Started by riv66724 pages
riv6672 Senior Member

Originally posted by krisblaze
She has lost many fights, don't worry.

I believe it.
Hyperbole is fine but not when its passed off as fact.
And the whole top tier thing? That lends itself to even more well, double talk.
WW has lost, but not to top tiers.
So, if a thread's made where she's pitted against a lower tier character there HAS to be a precedent for her losing to characters of that level? Right?
So saying she's never been beaten by a top tier is not an issue in those cases.
Honestly, can you see the snake eating its tail with this type of mish mash logic?

pym-ftw Mizukage

@Abhi

Yes a strength feat needs to be measurable to be quantifiable.

@Riv

I don't think Man-Thing has lost a fight.

abhilegend Prince of All Saiyans

Originally posted by pym-ftw
@Abhi

Yes a strength feat needs to be measurable to be quantifiable.

@Riv

I don't think Man-Thing has lost a fight.


That's some shitty criteria right there. Mongul and Non together couldn't handle that fissure and it was going to destroy phantom zone, an entire dimension. But its not a strength feat?

facepalm

pym-ftw Mizukage

It's not quantifiable... I'm not sure where we are hitting such a snag.

It's the same reason BoE, Sky lifting, Yddrasil pulling stuff is left out of debates.

Sure you can use it to say she is >Mongul but what has he done of any value...

krisblaze Senior Member

Originally posted by abhilegend
Really isn't a quantifiable feat? Does every strength feat has to be lifting a known weight or punching it? How many people in herald tier can boast to close a reality fissure with bare hands anyway?

I don't know.

I'd have to check my reality fissure feat list. Think I've got one in word or something.

Originally posted by abhilegend
I said people from top tier category.
She has lost to someone in herald category? Remind me again who did it?

What is top tier? Is that herochat terminology? Would you be better off there?

I consider the greek shitgods heralds.

pym-ftw Mizukage

Obviously if you beat WW your above Herald level...jeez

ODG Find Your Own Fire

Originally posted by thingy150
Obviously she has not gone through the same situation in a comic, most of the battles we make do not have scans in comics to match them.
Wolverine probably hasn't fought 100 grizzly bears, sure, but to say that most of the battle threads we come up with have absolutely no precedent in comics is uninformed at best, ignorant at worst.

There really is nothing else to be said at this point.

abhilegend Prince of All Saiyans

Originally posted by pym-ftw
It's not quantifiable... I'm not sure where we are hitting such a snag.

It's the same reason BoE, Sky lifting, Yddrasil pulling stuff is left out of debates.

Sure you can use it to say she is >Mongul but what has he done of any value...


Those are really high feats there. This is not in that category.
Originally posted by krisblaze
I don't know.

I'd have to check my reality fissure feat list. Think I've got one in word or something.

What is top tier? Is that herochat terminology? Would you be better off there?

I consider the greek shitgods heralds.


Not sure if serious or joking. But Superman has closed and pulled open fissures in reality with his hands, Thor and Hercules had closed a portal and that's it from heralds.

And I use top tiers and heralds interchangeably. Sue me.

thingy150 Restricted

Originally posted by ODG
Wolverine probably hasn't fought 100 grizzly bears, sure, but to say that most of the battle threads we come up with have absolutely no precedent in comics is uninformed at best, ignorant at worst.

There really is nothing else to be said at this point.

Obviously she has not gone through the same situation, are you joking with your posts? I gave a reason as to why she could clear and you are acting like i did not. Obviously she did not go through a gauntlet in the comics.

You have done nothing to prove that she cant clear, your posts a moot and childishly stupid at best.

riv6672 Senior Member

Haha, wow@this page. Or, wow, haha@this page.

ODG Find Your Own Fire

Originally posted by thingy150
Obviously she has not gone through the same situation, are you joking with your posts? I gave a reason as to why she could clear and you are acting like i did not. Obviously she did not go through a gauntlet in the comics.

You have done nothing to prove that she cant clear, your posts a moot and childishly stupid at best.

So Wonder Woman has never gone through a gauntlet of opponents before? Or busted a team before? Ever in the history of her comics? I mean, is this an observation from your reading of Wonder Woman comics or just some over-generalization you're making about comic characters, comic fights and forum threads in general? Based on your initial retort, it certainly sounded like the latter.

In which case, if you're just talking about what you think would happen without even considering what's done in comics, then this conversation is over.

krisblaze Senior Member

Originally posted by abhilegend
Not sure if serious or joking.

I was joking.
Originally posted by abhilegend
And I use top tiers and heralds interchangeably. Sue me.

I would if I could.

Top Tier doesn't even make any sense. Herald is not the top tier.

riv6672 Senior Member

I am amazed at how people use the same arguments they bash in one thread to make their point in another.

How high is DCnu stamina, BTW? The actual debate hinges more on that, i think, than raw power.