Originally posted by NephthysA chair and desk is a negligible inconsistency which has nothing to do with the prison cell.
There's confirmed inconsistencies between the sources.Theres no other examples of beskar being made into transparisteel.
Fry wrote the novel before the scene was created and the cells were established.
So tbh, I have more support than you do tbh.
There are as you can see from my awesome quote above.
Right, but the script would have been written so he would have had a good plan for the novel.
Nah you don't bro. Your only evidence is that you think Mandalorians are retards and that you don't like Savage having better feats than Satele. Like, it's a fact in Legends Canon that Savage busted a prison cell made from Mandalorian Iron. The Episode doesn't spell it out for us that it's made of Beskar but it also doesn't say it isn't, and given the renowned metal-work of the Mandalorians, and the common sense theory of using Beskar for prison cells, and my source above, it only makes sense for the cell to be Beskar, which is why Jason Fry wrote that it was made from Beskar TBH!
I found the source for that quote btw, it's from the 501st novel.
Beskar is a uniquely resistant iron that develops a wide range of properties-and colors-in the hands of skilled metalsmiths. Depending on the alloy, it can take any form from plate, laminate, and wire to foam, mesh, micronized particles, and even a transparent film. Mandalorians jealously guard their beskar-working skills and refuse to sell the formulas for any price; attempts to reproduce finished beskar elsewhere have been disappointing. The ore is found solely on Mandalore, and only Mandalorians know how to work it to maximize its extraordinary properties. Therefore if you want beskar, you must take Mandalore. But that inevitably proves easier to say than to do.- From Strategic Resources of the Galaxy, by Pilas Manaitis
- Taken from 501st
You're being childish. Calm down.
Originally posted by ILS
A chair and desk is a negligible inconsistency which has nothing to do with the prison cell.There are as you can see from my awesome quote above.
Right, but the script would have been written so he would have had a good plan for the novel.
Nah you don't bro. Your only evidence is that you think Mandalorians are retards and that you don't like Savage having better feats than Satele. Like, it's a fact in Legends Canon that Savage busted a prison cell made from Mandalorian Iron. The Episode doesn't spell it out for us that it's made of Beskar but it also doesn't say it isn't, and given the renowned metal-work of the Mandalorians, and the common sense theory of using Beskar for prison cells, and my source above, it only makes sense for the cell to be Beskar, which is why Jason Fry wrote that it was made from Beskar TBH!
Other than the description of the prison cell being the whole feat.
Well, your quote says a transparent film, not glass. But I guess it may indicate it's possible.
But not for the specifics of the cells apparently.
No, you just accused me of thinking they are retards to distract from the argument. Though the fact that one of the guards fires at a stationary Savage's back and misses instead of sounding the alarm that they've escaped doesn't suggest competence to me tbh.
Regardless though, I wouldn't consider it a better feat than Satele's. Just because one source says transparisteel retains most of its durability, while wookiee claims its not nearly as strong as durasteel, doesn't suggest the same for beskar. And the glass was still extremely thin and brittle. While Satele has crushed large, highly durable droids into cubes and blown them apart, casually.
Other than the description of the prison cell being the whole feat.We had a visual description of the cell in TCW which doesn't disprove Fry or the two sources me and Wolf provided.
Well, your quote says a transparent film, not glass. But I guess it may indicate it's possible.Awesome.
But not for the specifics of the cells apparently.Specifics speshmificks, that's what novels and sourcebooks are for.
No, you just accused me of thinking they are retards to distract from the argument. Though the fact that one of the guards fires at a stationary Savage's back and misses instead of sounding the alarm that they've escaped doesn't suggest competence to me tbh.Tbh the competency of the Mandalorians has little to do with the contents of the cell glass, I was just making a point of it that the Mandalorians being retards isn't a viable argument.
Regardless though, I wouldn't consider it a better feat than Satele's. Just because one source says transparisteel retains most of its durability, while wookiee claims its not nearly as strong as durasteel, doesn't suggest the same for beskar. And the glass was still extremely thin and brittle. While Satele has crushed large, highly durable droids into cubes and blown them apart, casually.lol dude why would it be different for Beskar? Wookiee isn't canon.
Thin? Sure. But there was a whole wall of the stuff. Brittle? LOLno tbh. It's Beskar.
I mean that's nice but can those droids take repeated strikes from a lightsaber blade? Or nah? latter tbh