I feel Zallow would give a very solid fight, but Jinn is overall the more proven fighter. Although if Zallow had been expounded on more as a fighter I wouldn't find it far-fetched for him to be in Jinn's tier.
@neph, just curious, which source was it that stated the Sith Zallow was blitzing were the best in the empire?
When has Jinn ever been irrefutably stated as a peer for Windu? In the Power of the Jedi Sourcebook I found a quote which pretty much contradicts this. The only other quote I know of is when Anoon Bondara was said to be humbled by superior duelists "like Jinn and Windu", but that only tells us Anoon is inferior to them, not that they are comparable.
Originally posted by Revanchiste
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I5W4GYh6QRE&index=7&list=PLIA1zt8Lh3E2JEOtqP6txQGOA6N3qk19a
One of the best Vs. videos I've ever seen. I honestly don't see how anyone who isn't a complete fanboy/girl could disagree with such a sensible and well-thought outcome.