Shang vs Batman

Started by Prof. T.C McAbe3 pages

Batman 9/10

Originally posted by deathslash
no he didn't! All he says is that he has weapons that make his stronger. No where in his statements does he say that he was given those for the specific purpose of that fight. Since he was also using those all the way back in the infinity book and still had them in his possession long after that fight, you can't say that it was a one time amp.
Shang Chi's been wearing the Stark gauntlets in every Avengers and Avengers-related appearance since he was indoctrinated into the Avengers World team. You only have to read his actual appearances to know that. Ignore him the same way he ignored the above scans and every recent comic involving Shang Chi.

Surely multiple instances of on-panel evidence don't count?

Originally posted by ODG
Shang Chi's been wearing the Stark gauntlets in every Avengers and Avengers-related appearance since he was indoctrinated into the Avengers World team. You only have to read his actual appearances to know that. Ignore him the same way he ignored the above scans and every recent comic involving Shang Chi.

abhi has never cared about facts, I thought that was common knowledge.

Originally posted by SamZED
I'm just a whore. The scan thing is a completely unrelated issue. 😄

Haha

Originally posted by KingD19
Surely multiple instances of on-panel evidence don't count?
IWhat on panel instances bro,?
Originally posted by Silent Master
abhi has never cared about facts, I thought that was common knowledge.

Coming from you snake-eyes? Laughable.

Originally posted by abhilegend
IWhat on panel instances bro,?
Coming from you snake-eyes? Laughable.
so then you still haven't bothered to look at the scans that ODG posted on the second page?

Originally posted by deathslash
so then you still haven't bothered to look at the scans that ODG posted on the second page?

I did. Those aren't proof of those gauntlets being on him since the avengers started though.

No gauntlets and gadgets. Shang wins.

^ It's Shang Chi vs Batman without any special stipulations. That means standard gear, i.e., Stark-gear and Bat-gadgets. It's a tough fight.

Under those stips, I'll usually go with Bats over better h2h fighters. He's sneakier, and is expert in using his suit/gadgets to overcome huge odds.

In a hand to hand fight Batman, i've been reading up on some of Shang's material and aside from chi he's never really struck me as some uber h2h fighter. I think he gets a lot of unfair hype because black panthers statement and his supposed fights with iron fist some decades ago.

Then theres the fact that Bruce has better physicalls, especially in the New 52 where he's practically superhuman in strength and striking power ei one shotting giant robots or kicking motorcycles in half or if you want to really go overboard, beating the crap out of a superman level opponent

Originally posted by riv6672
Under those stips, I'll usually go with Bats over better h2h fighters. He's sneakier, and is expert in using his suit/gadgets to overcome huge odds.

He doesn't needs hi gadgets here. He is superior in skills, brains and will take it easily.

Prolly take Bats because of gear.

Originally posted by Prof. T.C McAbe
He doesn't needs hi gadgets here. He is superior in skills, brains and will take it easily.

On that we disagree.
Batman's not a pure MA like Shang, otherwise he'd run around in a Bat Gi. Batman uses MA as part of a well put together offense/defense that combines a ton of different skill sets, tech.

Originally posted by riv6672
On that we disagree.
Batman's not a pure MA like Shang, otherwise he'd run around in a Bat Gi. Batman uses MA as part of a well put together offense/defense that combines a ton of different skill sets, tech.
That's like saying Thing is stronger than Silver Surfer because SS isn't a pure strength character.

No it isnt, but if dumbing my reasoning down to that level helps YOU out in any way, feel free. 👆

Originally posted by riv6672
No it isnt, but if dumbing my reasoning down to that level helps YOU out in any way, feel free. 👆
It sounds like it

Batman isn't pure MA so he's inferior to someone who is. That's a pretty weak argument

No, THIS is a weak argument. Have fun, pursuing it without me. 😂

Originally posted by riv6672
No, THIS is a weak argument. Have fun, pursuing it without me. 😂
Then why don't you clarify what you meant then? To avoid any more potential strawmans