ROTS Sidious/Dooku/Grievous vs. Talzin, Maul, Ventress, Savage

^
I wouldn't say, that Fisto was above Kolar or Tiin. He just had much more time to react, as he was the last Jedi that was attacked by Sidious. And he had Mace on his side.

Anyway, even if Sidious would be able to blitz Savage or Assaj, I doubt that Talzin would let that happen. Talzin probably would attack him with her lightning, and Sidious' answer would be his own lightning.
If this is Talzin from SoD, then on neutral ground Sidious would be able to overhelm her much faster. So Talzin's team have to react somehow.

Originally posted by McP
^
I wouldn't say, that Fisto was above Kolar or Tiin. He just had much more time to react, as he was the last Jedi that was attacked by Sidious. And he had Mace on his side.

Actually, in RotS Novel, Fisto and Windu managed to fight together a little longer than the Movie, and Gillard said that they had to make short that fight sequence in the movie due to time limit, so yeah Fisto was one level ahead of Tiin and Kolar.

In the comic book, similar to novel. Tiin and Kolar dies at the same time, while Fisto actually fought for a while.

http://i1273.photobucket.com/albums/y418/karasakal_teach/StarWars-EpisodeIII-RevengeoftheSith03-05_zps10ab0c43.jpg

http://i1273.photobucket.com/albums/y418/karasakal_teach/StarWars-EpisodeIII-RevengeoftheSith03-06_zps03d16e67.jpg

http://i1273.photobucket.com/albums/y418/karasakal_teach/StarWars-EpisodeIII-RevengeoftheSith03-07_zps3312647e.jpg

Kit Fisto >> Maul tbh

ILS, secret Sidious fanboy >> pathetic tbh

@Marco

It was not because of Fisto's superior skill. In the comic and book, Sidious catched them off-guard. Fisto saw how Sidious killed them, and was a bit more prepered for his speed then those two.

Originally posted by McP
@Marco

It was not because of Fisto's superior skill. In the comic and book, Sidious catched them off-guard. Fisto saw how Sidious killed them, and was a bit more prepered for his speed then those two.

Caught them off guard ? Tiin and Kolar at the same time ? They already knew Sidious was a sith lord, and they knew he was going to attack them. I don't see any caught by off guard here.

By surprise in the comic, and off-guard in the book.
They tried to arrest him at that point.

You can catch one of them by surprise, but two ? I highly doubt that.

Originally posted by Marco1907
Caught them off guard ? Tiin and Kolar at the same time ? They already knew Sidious was a sith lord, and they knew he was going to attack them. I don't see any caught by off guard here.

Tbf he probably bullrushed those 2. And neither of them had Windu fighting alongside them.

Originally posted by Marco1907
Both Ventress and Savage are good as Fisto, in fact Savage already proved he is better than Fisto against Sheev.

Both Ventress and Savage > Fisto tbh.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER

Both Ventress and Savage > Fisto tbh.

In dueling only ? I agree with dueling, but in overall they are comparable sword fighters tbh.

Fisto >>> Maul and Savage tbh

Originally posted by Marco1907
In dueling only ? I agree with dueling, but in overall they are comparable sword fighters tbh.

What's the difference?

I think they're both better than Fisto in Saber/Physical combat and in the Force.

Ventress was =/> Luminara who according to the official site was known for her "Incredible" Saber skills. And Ventress had grown more powerful since then.

She was also > Fisto in Cestus Deception. And again has been confirmed to have grown more powerful since then.

And Opress overpowered end of S4 Ventress. Although tbf she was restricted to 1 Saber and not her usual style.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
What's the difference?

Big difference here is lightsaber styles. Ventress is not a very special sword fighter in my point of view, but she is very good at dueling. And that is because her style makashi. Same for Fisto, he is very good in overall but sucks at dueling due to shii-cho's incompetency at lightsaber to lightsaber duels.

Being a sword master is not all about dueling, there are more threats than just lightsaber wielder opponents, such as blaster wielder opponents or wild creatures, droids etc.

^ Ah I see the difference you're making.