Star Wars Tier list

Originally posted by carthage
Does anyone want to make a community Tier list like the Comics subforum?

Sure. But it will be impossible for me to agree, that Plo, Kenobi or Mundi shlould be in the same tier with Dooku, Mace or Vader. They are at least a tier below.
I really have no idea, why you want to place loosers and cowards like Mundi in the same tier with powerhouses like Vader.

I never stated Mundi, Plo, or Kenobi are in the same tier as Mace, Dooku, or Vader. The latter (Mace) honestly is a bit overrated, but skillfully speaking those three are both a tier or so above the duelists you listed.

See the newest thread I made for more details.

Originally posted by carthage
In all honesty not a bad list McP, Ulic, Kolar, Bulq, Kenobi Mundi, Plo, and Kyle should all be tier 8 and Kas'im, Bane, Satele, Zannah, tier 6 or low tier 7

Since I place Dooku Mace and Vader in Tier 8, I thought that you want place those guys in the same tier with them.

Dooku, Mace, and Vader are all more or less equally skilled (tier 9 duelists), I said that guys like Plo, Bulq, Mundi are all at least half a tier to a full tier beneath them.

Lmfao to Vader being skilled as Mace and Dooku. Vader does not have any lightsaber dueling feats to suggest that he is that good, Anakin yes, Vader no.

You can see how skilled Maul really is with this comparison here ;

YouTube video

You're forgetting the three panels Maul spent fighting them prior to that page, making the time of Maul defeating them roughly equivalent to Anakin's.

It's better than Anakin's feat. He didn't get any shot from them, and destroyed them easier.

Too bad for you, it contradicts with your ''skill tier'' where Anakin one tier ahead of Maul.

You're totally right.

Not really. As I remember, every Magnaguard as it's own skill. Depends of how many Jedi it's fought etc.

I don't know how someone can put Mace at the same level with Asajj and Sora in the Force, or Shaak Ti, Mara and Plo is more powerful than Mace ?

He is at least powerful as Darth Maul and Dooku at TK, and he has also shatterpoint.

Originally posted by McP
Not really. As I remember, every Magnaguard as it's own skill. Depends of how many Jedi it's fought etc.

I don't remember that, still they are same level and TCW Darth Maul did better than Anakin.

So, is Nahdar Vebb aboce Anakin as well?

Originally posted by McP
So, is Nahdar Vebb aboce Anakin as well?

Nahdar Vebb fought against 4 magna at the same time ? I don't remember that, I remember when he defeated them one by one, even though that is irrelevant to the subject since clearly Nahdar is not in high level duelists tier.

Originally posted by Marco1907
I don't know how someone can put Mace at the same level with Asajj and Sora in the Force, or Shaak Ti, Mara and Plo is more powerful than Mace ?

He is at least powerful as Darth Maul and Dooku at TK, and he has also shatterpoint.

Additionally, y'know, the freaking Palpatine fight!

He had some help from the B-team to absorb the initial rush, but no-one did that well again against Sidious until Dark Empire, and a lot of it was his force defense. He could block lightning better than Yoda could.

Oh, and from the first CW, the Grievous chest crush.

Originally posted by Q99
He could block lightning better than Yoda could.

Let's not go overboard.

I don't remember Yoda screaming from the pain of Sidious's FL. And Yoda was deflecting it with his bare hands no less.

But as for the rest of your post, yes it's pretty obvious Mace > Maul in the Force just looking at their fights with Palpatine.

The Op's list is better than anything you guys are saying.