ROTS Sidious/Obi wan/Mace Windu vs. Darth Caedus/Darth Plagueis/Agen Kolar

Started by carthage2 pages
carthage PLEASE PROTECT ME STONES

ROTS Sidious/Obi wan/Mace Windu vs. Darth Caedus/Darth Plagueis/Agen Kolar

Battle takes place on neutral ground

Trocity Undefeated and Undisputed

Team 2, this is basically Sidious vs Caedus and Plagueis.

carthage PLEASE PROTECT ME STONES

What? Kenobi can hold his own against Kolar?

Trocity Undefeated and Undisputed

Damn, didn't see Agen.

Team 2 roflstomps based on the fact that Kolar would have beaten Sidious if he hadn't of been caught off guard.

NewGuy01 perpetual

Likely Team 1, but it should be a fairly even match.

|King Joker| Your Excellency

Sidious>Caedus
Mace>Plagueis
Kenobi>Kolar imo

Trocity Undefeated and Undisputed

Plagueis destroys Mace then destroys Agen for Kenobi then they gang Sidious.

ares834 Senior Member

Team 1.

Board Walker Senior Member

Caedus > Sidious

Kolar > Sidious

Plagueis > Windu

Obi Wan dies instantly from the AOE damage at the start of the fight.

NewGuy01 perpetual
Originally posted by Board Walker
Kolar > Sidious

You please me.

carthage PLEASE PROTECT ME STONES

Going with team 2. Mace doesn't strike me as much of an obstacle with a morals off setting.

ILS Restricted

Why is Plagueis being compared to people like Mace and Jaina recently? He's beyond them.

Arhael Devoid of reality

Originally posted by ILS
Why is Plagueis being compared to people like Mace and Jaina recently? He's beyond them.

Based on what? He haven't fought anyone of note. He has no feats.

carthage PLEASE PROTECT ME STONES

Lmao

ILS Restricted
Originally posted by carthage
Lmao
Arhael Devoid of reality

Originally posted by carthage
Lmao

Funny to hear that from you. You bash Bane every time pointing out how he never fought anyone of note. Plagueis Force feats may seem impressive but that's down to author's writing style. I not gonna put him above certain characters simply because author described his Force attack as "anything but atomized" the same way I wouldn't put Vitiate above certain characters for having infinitively more powerful lightning than lightning that turns to ash.

NewGuy01 perpetual

So if you write off character feats because of the author's writing style, what exactly makes one "significant" in the first place? Perhaps it only counts if it was written by one of Arhael's divine chosen.

Marco1907 Great Sith Lord

Plagueis was more powerful than TPM Sidious, and possibly same level with RotS Sidious.

Arhael Devoid of reality

Originally posted by NewGuy01
So if you write off character feats because of the author's writing style, what exactly makes one "significant" in the first place? Perhaps it only counts if it was written by one of Arhael's divine chosen.

Sidious and Yoda are most powerful that's the starting point for PT and other characters can be compared based on performance against them.
For NJO the only link is DE, where Luke fought Sidious.
When it comes to TOR area there is no way to compare characters, so I either don't involve or vote out of bias.

DARTH POWER Senior Member
Originally posted by Arhael
Sidious and Yoda are most powerful that's the starting point for PT and other characters can be compared based on performance against them.
For NJO the only link is DE, where Luke fought Sidious.
When it comes to TOR area there is no way to compare characters, so I either don't involve or vote out of bias.

Exactly! And it just becomes about whatever statements people can grasp at concerning which generation of Jedi/Sith were supposed to be the best.

You can compare feats, but that becomes problematic depending on how different authors and mediums portray force powers. What kind of amp was given by certain Nexus e.t.c.
I mean just going by feats Kanan and the Inquisitor actually seem pretty bad ass. But we've already been told outright that Vader or Kenobi would basically blitz either of them.

That's why I don't largely get involved with cross generational debates either.