DE Luke vs. RotS Sidious

Neutral setting.

Who wins?

*le sigh

Palpatine.

Luke already bested a more powerful version...

So Luke.

Luke wins.

Sidious, DE is BS, and Luke is almost featless at that point.

One of his feats is beating a more powerful version of Sidious.

"more powerful" version of Sidious

What are you trying to say?

So Crushing an AT-AT is being featless?

And yeah, not to mention defeating Palpatine in a Duel.

DE Luke > DE Sidious > ROTS Sidious, at least in combat that is.

Sidious

Luke.

Cause, as everyone else said, he already beat a better version.

Not even sure why this thread was made unless OP thinks ROTS is stronger then Dark Empire.