Dark Side Tournament Round 1: Lord Starkiller vs Darth Revan Reborn

The non-canon DS versions of game characters face off in a new series to crown the strongest as ultimate Dark Lord:

Lord Starkiller vs Darth Revan Reborn

Arena: Emperor's Throne Room, Second Death Star.

Incarnations:
Lord Starkiller from Star Wars The Force Unleashed Ultimate Sith Edition.
Darth Revan Reborn from the Dark Side ending of Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic.

Tournament Rules:

1.All-out, no amps.
2.ONLY Dark Side choice related events count as valid topics of discussion, canon Light Side choice related events will not count towards the final decision.
3.I will personally act as the judge to declare a winner in each round, the decision will be made through the best arguments and supporting evidence.
4.The made-up names I will use are totes cool.

Full list of Tournament Participants:

Lord Starkiller(TFU:USE)
Dark Jedi Exile(KOTOR2:TSL)
Darth Revan Reborn(KOTOR)
Emperor Slayer(SWTOR)
Child Slayer(SWTOR)
Darth Vader(ROTS:VG)

Awesome tournament. I always got the impression that Darth Revan Reborn would be more powerful then his canonical redeemed incarnation.

Interesting using Infinity characters, some are pretty powerful despite their short appearances.

Oh if it helps folks, I did make a respect thread for both Darth Starkiller and Dark Apprentice on CV.

http://www.comicvine.com/forums/gen-discussion-1/star-wars-darth-starkiller-dark-apprentice-respect-1627390/

Nice thread.

The fact that Leia can TK anything at all, let alone the Dark Clone, as the equivalent of a gimped ESB Luke is all the proof I need that TFU is ridiculous.

Dark Jedi Exile is basically Nihilus, kinda stomps to be honest.

As for this actual thread, dark Galen has some impressive feats. A dark enraged Luke Skywalker produced crimson lightning, which was kinda impressive. His raw potential would probably have made that close to Sidious level if not higher, so honestly if Marek can Tutaminis that he can take Revan.

I don't see Dark Revan as being much more powerful than his canon incarnation, where Galen surely is.

Also I liked the Child Slayer name tbh.

Originally posted by Selenial
Dark Jedi Exile is basically Nihilus, kinda stomps to be honest.

As for this actual thread, dark Galen has some impressive feats. A dark enraged Luke Skywalker produced crimson lightning, which was kinda impressive. His raw potential would probably have made that close to Sidious level if not higher, so honestly if Marek can Tutaminis that he can take Revan.

I don't see Dark Revan as being much more powerful than his canon incarnation, where Galen surely is.

Infinites Luke was pretty powerful, he was able to block/absorb Starkiller's Lighting, blocking and using saber throw, tear off a door with TK, Force Push Starkiller clear across the hanger, TK close a Blast Door like nothing. As Fallen Luke, he was able to Force Repulse 3 Snowtroopers and use Force Lighting as ya said.

He was also trained by Obi-Wan's spirit. So...yeah, even Infinities Luke was pretty powerful.

Originally posted by Selenial
Dark Jedi Exile is basically Nihilus, kinda stomps to be honest.

Not on his scale. DS Exile is stronger than the regular one, because she killed and drained the Masters but I don't imagine thats a massive difference.

Thank you everyone but if we can, let's debate the current battle.

Who has better saber abilities? Who has greater command of the Dark Side? Who survives to make it to the finale?

Revan.

I believe we're trying to establish power levels and reach a collective consensus. And it's actually pretty refreshing compared to what we usually do here, honestly.

Ant, Want to make any argument for that? After-all that's how I'm deciding the winner.

Freshest, I was more talking about Exile talk, power level debating is fine.

Better feats and hype.

Perhaps, we'll see.

IMO. Lord Starkiller has the saber edge. I'm inclined to give him the force edge, but that's only because of Revan's lack of force showings during Kotor. Unless I'm forgetting something which is highly unlikely(coughbullshitcough). That's just my two cents tho. Looking forward to the rest of the tourney. Awesome start 😄

@AP: Not really.

Ant, I would put on serious mode if you want Revan to win this thing, Fated's opinion I can imagine will be most popular.

At that point Vader was already heavily damaged.

Lord Starkiller was ridiculous though. Even able to kill Spirit Kenobi (lol).

Originally posted by AncientPower
Ant, I would put on serious mode if you want Revan to win this thing, Fated's opinion I can imagine will be most popular.