Luke, Cade and Jaina vs. Plagueis, Maul and Bane

* This is DE Luke, SoD Maul and DoE Bane. All others are at their best.

Setting: Naboo plains

Who wins?

Team 1 solidly

Plagueis can handle Luke but either 3 of the Jedi would LOLSTOMP Bane. Maul would lose to Luke and at the very least hold off Jaina, but Luke is more skillful than Plagueis and while Hego is strong- Luke deflecting ATT fire leads me to believe he could absorb his telekinetic attacks and best him in a duel.

Going with the Jedi 6-7/10

Bane is such a weak link it's not even funny. Replace him with someone more useful like Savage or Cin Drallig.

Bane's the weak link. Team 1.

Luke defeated Sidious, and Plagueis, try though he might, is no Sidious.

Team Skywalker by a landslide.

Not by a landslide, Maul could probably take Jaina in a duel. But Bane would die to either Cade or Jaina, and Cade can at least hold his own against Maul long enough due to his force abilities.

Maul take Jaina? Jaina, the gal who takes on her brother, arguably the #2 Sith in history? At best, Maul's her equal with a saber, but he's got nothing on a Skywalker in the force.

There are plenty of to either duel between Jacen and Jaina. Unassisted and without Luke's aid and with Caedus in prime condition, Caedus is superior to Jaina in every way

Maul is physically superior, roughly as skilled, and probably only slightly less powerful. Apart from her circumstantial showings against Caedus, Maul is a better duelist in my opinion

I think Jaina outclasses Maul considerably in the Force, but eh. If the martial arts section is a draw (Boba Fett counters Maul's Teris Kaze), then it comes down to the Force, and Maul can't really win that on TK or telepathy. And she's got shatterpoint too.

On the contrary, Maul's actual feats with the Force are actually much better and commonplace than Jaina's. I remember you said something similar on the topic of Dooku vs Maul, so I'm gonna go out on a limb and infer that you're severely uneducated on the subject of Maul's force powers.

Team 2. The Bane hate is getting disgusting now.

It's not hate, it's just anti-wankery. There's no rain in this fight so Bane is of little use.

Or educated by the wrong source, at least. To be fair, I remember him most from the movie duel, and the Sidious vs. Maul and Opress fights. He wasn't using the Force much, if at all, in either.

Maul > Jaina in force use significantly. The most Jaina has done is throw some boulders.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Maul > Jaina in force use significantly. The most Jaina has done is throw some boulders.

Bane has only killed guards with TK, thrown a table, and broken a featless Sith Lord's spine 👆

He is nowhere near as powerful as Maul or Jaina.

Jaina has redirected bombs while simultaneously flying her Stealth X, redirected missiles, broken Darth Caedus's choke, collapsed a large portion of a wall, and shattered Plastoid/Beskar with shatterpoint. Her feats with the force are better than killing guards with telekinesis or breaking a table 👆

And what has Maul done that makes him better then Jaina?

A ton, actually. Here's a taste:

"Maul’s clenched right hand slammed down on the table, shattering its surface, and the vibroblade took flight, nearly impaling itself in his head. Straightening, he bared his filed teeth and tensed his body, close to loosing a scream that would have brought the barracks down around him."

-Restraint

Force Choking Kenobi, who has a notoriously weak force shield...collapsing a fighter over a ledge, not by pulling the fighter, but by collapsing a strut and letting gravity do the rest...and sending some non force sensitives flying. That's not really enough to overcome Jaina, and collapsing a tunnel is something Mara's done equally well. On Caedus's head, no less.

She collapsed that tunnel with maximum effort on her part.

Maul sent Kenobi flying while simultaneously destroying it. Its somewhat of a better showing, granted I don't think Maul would have a force edge against Jaina if she can break Caedus's choke.