SF Malak vs. DoE Bane

SWL
These individuals do not fight Jedi and/or Sith in direct manner, they rely on impressive gadgets and firepower to contend with Force-user opponents.

I personally believe that even a buffed-up and heavily armed individual shouldn't pose a threat to a well-trained Force-user, not a Sith Lord at least, but this is Star Wars and logic is not its strong forte.

So we are left to hold Carth in the same regard as we do with Jango and other incredibly competent combatants amongst the normal folk.

---

You think that these are impressive? Explore Grand Champion of SWTOR for a change. This guy pulled off shit that many Jedi won't. Heck, he might even take Count Dooku, and I am not kidding.

This was goofy. The rest is sound, if not absolute. As long as you apply the same standard with both parties (Bane and Malak), you might have a good case here.

I'll leave the rest to Dmb, Neph, or Neb. It'll be interesting to watch. You've piqued my interest.

I don't see the issue. Carth shot at Malak who easy blocked everything and Force-pwned him just like you guys say should happen when a muggle fights a force user. :T

You're to do battle with SWL on this subject at your earliest convenienceright now.

I don't see why this subject is contentious enough to cause conflict.

It's not contentious. I would be interested in the debate, though, since I'm quite honestly open to either outcome.

Oh, you meant on Malak vs Bane. I thought you meant the Carth thing.

Well given that Malak got shat on by Revan over and over and over again even in this incarnation and after Revan had gone through an army and given that Bane is superior to Kotor Revan by quite a bit, I'm fairly certain no one is contesting that Bane can snap Malaks head off at least once. Legend thinking Malak can give a good fight before perishing horribly isn't notable enough for a debate. I disagree but whatever.

Although I laughed when he brought up lighting and drain, considering Bane's application of both abilities far exceeds Malak's meager attempts.

Originally posted by Trocity
Legend's TOR bias is cringe worthy. The irony in his comments make me guffaw regularly. He can twist shit to make TOR characters look more impressive and then turn around and shit on characters from other eras with similar showings.

Kol Skywalker shitting on a mountain of sith and stormtroopers not being as impressive as Darach's one fight scene because "Kol was in a comic book so it's hard to tell how good he actually is" is, quite frankly, lolworthy.

Also, what makes you think that Darach cannot smoke many no-name Sith and stormtroopers? As for Kol, I simply stated that not enough is known about him to consider in versus scenarios against detailed characters.

Originally posted by ILS
Bane deflecting rain is the fastest speed feat in the mythos because of that one guys fan calc.

There was nothing wrong with Zampano's calculation and referring to it as a fan calculation does nothing to invalidate it, but it's nice to see you're still sore over the crushing defeat you suffered at the hands of my padawan. 😂

Also, you should argue for Bane more often Temp, it suits you. and pleases me most greatly.

Originally posted by flirtatious padawan learner
Although I laughed when he brought up lighting and drain, considering Bane's application of both abilities far exceeds Malak's meager attempts.

Is that a typo and did you mean to say lightning and rain, because Bane is too fast for both.

*Lightning.

SF Malak is borderline relativistic by feats. He blitzes.

Malak

Bane's force feats aren't powerful to do anything to him, and his lightning can be dodged or deflected.

Beating Revan is superior to any feat he's ever done

Originally posted by Nephthys
*Lightning.

Wow, I didn't see that you had actually indeed made a typo there, I was referring to where you said drain and wanted to slip in Bane's godly rain feat.

Originally posted by ares834
SF Malak is borderline relativistic by feats. He blitzes.

what??

Idiots on the Naruto forums calculated that based on the ships and their weaponsfire outside the window in the Malak fight, the whole thing was taking place at near relativistic speeds.

Lol @ making fun of them when you put Bane on Sidious's level and wank his rain feat

Stop talking to me.

Originally posted by appletonia
There was nothing wrong with Zampano's calculation and referring to it as a fan calculation does nothing to invalidate it, but it's nice to see you're still sore over the crushing defeat you suffered at the hands of my padawan. 😂

Also, you should argue for Bane more often Temp, it suits you. and pleases me most greatly.

IIRC you lost to Tempest pretty badly in that Kun vs Krayt thread a while back. But more to the point Bane dies in this fight