Originally posted by ares834
Filoni doesn't care about the EU TBF and considered it non-canon. However, the movies make it clear that Han can understand Chewie.
Well right, I'm just saying, what is shown in the movies with Han understanding Chewie. Fits with what is shown in the EU material about Han.
Originally posted by ILS
I wasn't aware that I was crying, but I'll continue crying as you request. And duly noted. Although preferably I would like a creator statement spoon feeding me the information that Grievous does indeed suck.
Well Lucas is his creator and he's called him a cowardly villain (ROTS Audio commentary), and it was under his specific orders he was to suck against a few Gungans 😂
But don't worry ILS, Lucas is a nobody. His notions obviously mean squat. So any protege of his(Ahem... Filoni) will obviously be an insignificant source.
Originally posted by The_Tempest
I sense much anger in you.
Not really. Just stating a fact. Sidious sucks too.
Originally posted by DARTH POWERMan, those gungans must be pretty legit! Being able to prep for Grievous and win is no mean feat.
Well Lucas is his creator and he's called him a cowardly villain (ROTS Audio commentary), and it was under his specific orders he was to suck against a few Gungans 😂But don't worry ILS, Lucas is a nobody. His notions obviously mean squat. So any protege of his(Ahem... Filoni) will obviously be an insignificant source.
What do you mean DARTH POWER? Lucas is almighty and what he says goes, and his protege Dave Filoni who gets rather basic events from the movies wrong is obviously an expert in the field of Star Wars. I don't know how you have come to the conclusion that Lucas is a nobody and Filoni is an insignificant source. Could you elucidate on this further for us?
Originally posted by ILS
Man, those gungans must be pretty legit! Being able to prep for Grievous and win is no mean feat.What do you mean DARTH POWER? Lucas is almighty and what he says goes, and his protege Dave Filoni who gets rather basic events from the movies wrong is obviously an expert in the field of Star Wars. I don't know how you have come to the conclusion that Lucas is a nobody and Filoni is an insignificant source. Could you elucidate on this further for us?
Of course Filoni has no say. He's only the biggest creator of SW Tv Canon, a consultant to the Lucasfilm Story Group, and Lucas's protege.
But really, what does all that mean? F*** all man. I'd much rather take your own years of SW Non-Canon Eu Legends reading, and your totally non-biased years of Loving up Grievous any day.
Originally posted by DARTH POWERAnd it's only befitting for a man of such status to be so poorly informed on the main Star Wars source material - the movies. Anyone who listens to what he has to say are among the most knowledgeable of all Star Wars lore. Filthy novel reading peasants be damned, what Filoni says goes!
Of course Filoni has no say. He's only the biggest creator of SW Tv Canon, a consultant to the Lucasfilm Story Group, and Lucas's protege.But really, what does all that mean? F*** all man. I'd much rather take your own years of SW Non-Canon Eu Legends reading, and your totally non-biased years of Loving up Grievous any day.
You would? I'm flattered that you put so much stock into my wisdom 😉
I truly believe we're on the same page here, DP.
Originally posted by ILS
And it's only befitting for a man of such status to be so poorly informed on the main Star Wars source material - the movies. Anyone who listens to what he has to say are among the most knowledgeable of all Star Wars lore. Filthy novel reading peasants be damned, what Filoni says goes!You would? I'm flattered that you put so much stock into my wisdom 😉
Filoni's clearly never seen the whole of the Original SW trilogy. I reckon he saw the first one, then just read the rest on Wookiepedia. And his statements are all so literal and devoid of any context, which is why we should just ignore him.
I know right? Because only Legends novels are real novels. Canon novels are not real novels obviously, so reading them clearly doesn't count as reading.
Of course man, you the man! I've never come across someone like you who knows so much about SW that he can literally tell me when people at Lucasfilm don't know what they're talking about.
Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Filoni's clearly never seen the whole of the Original SW trilogy. I reckon he saw the first one, then just read the rest on Wookiepedia. And his statements are all so literal and devoid of any context, which is why we should just ignore him.
I know right? Because only Legends novels are real novels. Canon novels are not real novels obviously, so reading them clearly doesn't count as reading.
Of course man, you the man! I've never come across someone like you who knows so much about SW that he can literally tell me when people at Lucasfilm don't know what they're talking about.👆
All the....posts aside, Dave really should know at least the basics of the OT. See this is just proving a point, that people didn't really watch the movies. They watched them sure, but they didn't take everything in nor sometimes even the context of particular scenes even when it's right there.
I mean Dave is a nice guy and all, I liked TCW well enough even with some problems and I like Rebels despite its problems but...he really should know the stuff.