Malgus vs. Bane and Malak

Started by DarthAnt664 pages

:mmm: I might just stick him with you anyway. Probably not though. Zenix, what forum are you from?

You're free to do what you want kiddo

I'm just shooting the shit :maybe

Lol if you wanna talk about random stuff we probably shouldn't do it here. I'm from Oregon though.

Asked for your forum (aka your boards, like, this is KillerMovies or KMC), not your state. 😉

Ah rofl ya I didn't read that clearly. I'm not from any forums I've read them a fair amount and finally figured it would be fun to point a few things out instead of constantly face palming.

Not YouTube either?

Kind of funny how underrated Bane is though around here :maybe

If you ignore his Ruusan feats (ritual or not, that was only 27 sith shoving all their power into their strongest member more or less), his entire order of Sith are sort of jokes until you reach Tenebrous/Maybe Tenebrous' master in any quantifiable sense :hmm

Nope no credentials outside of reading tons of star wars books (most of them 5 or 6 times, I'm a addict) and comics and playing all the star wars games.

Bane isn't underrated here. Only people who lowball him are Carthage, ILS, and that one other guy no one pays attention to. They don't reflect the forum's actual views.

Originally posted by zEniX
Nope no credentials outside of reading tons of star wars books (most of them 5 or 6 times, I'm a addict) and comics and playing all the star wars games.

Fascinating. I have long waited for some new, credible debaters to come in since the arrival of my Outcast crew and SWTOR on KMC.
Only Freshest and Angel have lived up to my expectations. I'll bookmark your name for events to come: I don't want such potential wasted.

Originally posted by ChaosTheory123
Kind of funny how underrated Bane is though around here :maybe

If you ignore his Ruusan feats (ritual or not, that was only 27 sith shoving all their power into their strongest member more or less), his entire order of Sith are sort of jokes until you reach Tenebrous/Maybe Tenebrous' master in any quantifiable sense :hmm

Even with the Ruusan feats Bane has incredibly powerful feats like disintegrating people with lightning and tk, destroying the Lehon temple, moving fast enough to appear to be wielding a dozen lightsabers and to block all rain from hitting him in a 20 minute downpour as well as many other high class feats. Also recall that even if we ignore Banes part on Ruusan, Zannah was able to unconsciously shield herself from the firestorm Bane and the Sith unleashed. Which is also incredibly impressive.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Bane isn't underrated here. Only people who lowball him are Carthage, ILS, and that one other guy no one pays attention to. They don't reflect the forum's actual views.

Ah

Could they be a little more varied about it though?

The cookie cutter style of trolling is kind of... dull

I mean, if you're trying to piss people off, you'd think some effort would go into the act :hmm

Suppose they could just think you all aren't worth the effort, but then why bother in the first place when trying enjoy some schadenfreude?

Ah thanks for letting me know 😎

Originally posted by Nephthys
Even with the Ruusan feats Bane has incredibly powerful feats like disintegrating people with lightning and tk, destroying the Lehon temple, moving fast enough to appear to be wielding a dozen lightsabers and to block all rain from hitting him in a 20 minute downpour as well as many other high class feats. Also recall that even if we ignore Banes part on Ruusan, Zannah was able to unconsciously shield herself from the firestorm Bane and the Sith unleashed. Which is also incredibly impressive.

Let's just summarize it as my sense of scale from era to era is much different from yours, which is why I find the ruusan feat so relevant when evaluating members of the Rule of Two not named Plagueis or Sidious :maybe

Originally posted by Nephthys
Even with the Ruusan feats Bane has incredibly powerful feats like disintegrating people with lightning and tk, destroying the Lehon temple, moving fast enough to appear to be wielding a dozen lightsabers and to block all rain from hitting him in a 20 minute downpour as well as many other high class feats. Also recall that even if we ignore Banes part on Ruusan, Zannah was able to unconsciously shield herself from the firestorm Bane and the Sith unleashed. Which is also incredibly impressive.

I'm not saying this to low ball Zannah as I view her as on par with Bane and hold them both up pretty high but the shielding feat isn't as impressive as you make it sound.

"She remembered what Laa had said just before the entire forest
had exploded in flames: Bad dreams, Rain. Death dreams. The fires had killed most of the other bouncers. The survivors had all gone
mad.
All except Laa. Somehow Rain had saved her. She’d used the Force,
shielding them both from the burning death and destruction, though she
wasn’t quite sure how she’d done it. It had just sort of .. . happened. Now
she and Laa had nobody left but each other."

I would like to point out however that some bouncers clearly survived the inferno even without shielding, pointing to this not being that impressive of a feat for a full Sith, for a child though, definitely.

Originally posted by zEniX

I would like to point out however that some bouncers clearly survived the inferno even without shielding, pointing to this not being that impressive of a feat for a full Sith, for a child though, definitely.

The inverse square law is your friend

Your rebuttal and general understanding of the feat is crippled for not knowing what it is :maybe

I'm always happy to learn new fun stuff, but I don't see how my point requires me understanding anything other than that unshielded bouncers survived the same inferno.

P.S. I'm reading about the inverse square law atm thx

Literally just type inverse square law into google

If you don't understand why they're less harmed by an expanding mass of energy from a feasibly further distance away from the epicenter than Zannah was after that?

I really can't help you, because the concept probably went over your head and I have little patience to help you learn :maybe

That's not me trying to be rude or anything, I'm just incredibly lazy

Originally posted by ChaosTheory123
I really can't help you, because the concept probably went over your head and I have little patience to help you learn :maybe

There is nothing in the text to indicate the other bouncers were farther away from the epicenter than Zannah and Lah were however. Soooo it is irrelevant...