Superman/Captain Marvel/Martian Manhunter best showing

Originally posted by riv6672
DCnu versions.
Which of DCs arguably 3 most powerful mainstays does best against:

The Defenders:
1. Dr. Strange (classic)
2. Professor Hulk
3. Silver Surfer
3. Namor

And why?
Not a team vs team fight. Each is one on four.

As to who does the best :
1) Superman
2) Martian Manhunter
distant 3) Captain Marvel.

As to why :
1) Superman can possibly a) Speedblitz KO Strange, b) HV Namor, c) BFR Hulk. Even if he manages to pull that off perfectly, he has to deal with Surfer and none of those options are gonna work (and Surfer wouldn't just be standing around there twiddling his thumbs while Superman was working over his teammates).

2) Martian Manhunter can open by being intangible thus making Namor and Hulk's physical attacks useless. He can then try to mindblast them. Namor and possibly Hulk would fall but Strange and Surfer would still be standing.

3) Captain Marvel does the worst. He's not as versatile as Superman or MM. He's like a D list Superman.

Originally posted by zopzop
Obviously, all three of them lose.

As to who does the best :
1) Superman
2) Martian Manhunter
distant 3) Captain Marvel.

As to why :
1) Superman can possibly a) Speedblitz KO Strange, b) HV Namor, c) BFR Hulk. Even if he manages to pull that off perfectly, he has to deal with Surfer and none of those options are gonna work (and Surfer wouldn't just be standing around there twiddling his thumbs while Superman was working over his teammates).

2) Martian Manhunter can open by being intangible thus making Namor and Hulk's physical attacks useless. He can then try to mindblast them. Namor and possibly Hulk would fall but Strange and Surfer would still be standing.

3) Captain Marvel does the worst. He's not as versatile as Superman or MM. He's like a D list Superman.

Superman - he's got the best record of the three on versing teams. Still pointless pick because he'd get murdered by this team.
Shazam - gets murdered a little earlier.
Martian - gets murdered even earlier.

[moaning and hoping to come off as too good for the threads 🙂 ] Damage control

Your thread is stupid. I'm telling you why it makes no sense. My contributions have no say in the thought process of this thread.

You can not adequately compare people in a thread where they get wiped out in seconds. This thread has zero value as indicated by you continuing to bump the thread since it's useless. This isn't an eventually defeat incoming where a confrontation can be prolonged due to an inability to immediately end a fight but still hopeless. This is a stomp in seconds.

Way to take passive criticism so well though prior to this. Cue some butthurt because you spent so long thinking about such a stupid thread.[/moaning and hoping to come off as too good for the threads 🙂 ]

😆

Originally posted by zopzop
Obviously, all three of them lose.

As to who does the best :
1) Superman
2) Martian Manhunter
distant 3) Captain Marvel.

As to why :
1) Superman can possibly a) Speedblitz KO Strange, b) HV Namor, c) BFR Hulk. Even if he manages to pull that off perfectly, he has to deal with Surfer and none of those options are gonna work (and Surfer wouldn't just be standing around there twiddling his thumbs while Superman was working over his teammates).

2) Martian Manhunter can open by being intangible thus making Namor and Hulk's physical attacks useless. He can then try to mindblast them. Namor and possibly Hulk would fall but Strange and Surfer would still be standing.

3) Captain Marvel does the worst. He's not as versatile as Superman or MM. He's like a D list Superman.

Originally posted by riv6672
And thanks for getting the fact that none of them were supposed to win.

Illiteracy

Thanks for bumping my thread. 🙂

Two minutes after is a great bump.

But alright, last "bump". Wouldn't want to get the thread closed down. 🙂

Sure you would.😄

J'onn can be tactical at times. If he scans their minds he should be able to perceive that Norrin is the most dangerous and try to take him down with telepathy.

What is the glinting bastard's psi resistance?

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f95/t435617.html

This is a discussion on the subject from KMC itself...

Originally posted by riv6672
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f95/t435617.html

This is a discussion on the subject from KMC itself...

I rule that the Manhunter CAN overwhelm the Surfer psionically!

Based on...?
Not disagreeing, BTW. my knee jerk reaction is to concur.

The Martian. He's just as strong as Superman but his intangibility and telepathy is what gives him the edge over the other two

Surfer or Strange bfr instantly. Non fight and if bfr isn't available, surfer solos. Come at me

speed of light > speed of thought, MM or Superman KOs Strange

Originally posted by LordofBrooklyn
I rule that the Manhunter CAN overwhelm the Surfer psionically!

Your time away from the boards has driven you mad!

Originally posted by zopzop

Your time away from the boards has driven you mad!

I am THE KING OF CANON!

My judgements cannot be overruled!

J'onn has the feats to make Surfer his puppet!

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Surfer or Strange bfr instantly. Non fight and if bfr isn't available, surfer solos. Come at me

Surfer solos a lighweight herald like Thor.

The Glinting Bastard cannot pull it off against The Man of Steel or Marvel!

Meh. Surfer is everything Clark aspires to be. No contest