ROTS Sidious vs. Traya/Malgus/Kun

This incarnation of Sidious loses the majortity here imho.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Sidious one-shot Maul [b]and Savage at the start of the fight. He ragdolled them with them unable to break out despite straining against him. Then as soon as Sidious got bored at the end he started Lokismashing Maul. [/B]

Catching someome off-guard is very different from one-shotting A prepared opponent. Maul was never going to beat Sidious but his performance in and of itself is highly impressive.

...LOL at ANYBODY not named Luke soloing Sidious.

Yoda can and did fight him to a losing draw, Mace got superamped that once (and Sids might've been faking for Anakin's sake, it's unclear), but that's as close as it gets.

Caedus would beat him or at least give him a good fight.

Originally posted by Angelalex242
...LOL at ANYBODY not named Luke soloing Sidious.

The God Tiers go as a given, I don't feel the need to point them out every time. At any rate, not applicable here.

Caedus does put a heck of a fight, though. Probably 3-4 of 10.

Originally posted by AncientPower
Catching someome off-guard is very different from one-shotting A prepared opponent. Maul was never going to beat Sidious but his performance in and of itself is highly impressive.

Maul and Savage were straining and unable to break his force hold.

It is far harder to break a Force Grip than it is to block one entirely.

So much harder that Sidious can hold Maul AND Savage against their will, but can't ragdoll Maul if he's prepared? Despite actually doing that at the end of the fight? And being able to choke Dooku from across the galaxy.

At the end where Maul is spent certainly but Sidious is hardly one-shotting a prepared Darth Maul nor a prepared Dooku for that matter. That being said he would still beat both of them every time. My original point being that Maul is not being one-shotted by Darth Malgus, a roughly equal in strength opponent at best.

Originally posted by Angelalex242
The burden of proof is on you. Never ask someone to prove a negative.

It's on you to show he has feats equivalent to that of Plageuis or other similar Sith.

I already said that Exar Kun was the most powerful Dark Side energy Luke felt sense Palpatine.