Originally posted by krisblaze
@Leo and KMI think we're more off on the x/10 rating than how strong these characters are compared to one another.
I think it's entirely possible for a character to win 10/10 and still have a very close fight every time.
i agree with you that someone can go 10/10 and all fights be close. in this case though i just don't see it happening. i def think think namor could take some, and bb (who's had the advantage on glads a couple times and does just fine against hulk...) could certainly take some. simon is a bit all over but i could see him winning some too. taking a majority against each? i could get with you on that. but clean sweeps? even if each is close, can't see it. least not imo.
a legit question though kris--could you see him taking cap britain for a sweep as well?
and @abhi--thanks for the scans. i'd forgotten about that fight. doesn't change my mind in this case too much (i still don't see him winning every fight here, do you?) but i should have remembered that....
Originally posted by leonidas
(who's had the advantage on glads a couple times and does just fine against hulk...)
I don't think he would've survived much longer in either of those cases without his other powers.
Originally posted by leonidas
a legit question though kris--could you see him taking cap britain for a sweep as well?
I think Brian can take a win or two, but his losses might not be as close.
If Aquaman starts getting an advantage then Brian would probably do worse than say Sasquatch or Namor.
On the other hand it's possible for Brian to pull a win or two out of his ass by confidence boost, like when he's doing stuff like stalemating Phoenix or almost killing MJJ.
It's also possible walter goes great beast mode and eats aquaman 😇
I get the concept of 10/10 matches still being close. I still disagree him winning all of the matches. You said it yourself if it's close is it unreasonable to assume they couldn't swing the match their way? If we're using abc logic, black manta regularly goes hand to hand with Arthur and does very well. However, black manta foight deathstroke recently and it didn't go well for him.
Originally posted by -K-M-
I get the concept of 10/10 matches still being close. I still disagree him winning all of the matches. You said it yourself if it's close is it unreasonable to assume they couldn't swing the match their way?
Well, there's this devil of a question.
If 10/10 means that he wins 100% of the time, then it's not really accurate because he could trip and or some shit. Anything's possible.
Re: Aquaman vs
Originally posted by celeyhyga17
This is DCnU Arthur. Pure H2H. How well does he do against each opponent out of 10?Luke Cage
She-Hulk
Drax
Gamora
Thing
Colossus
Ares
Sasquatch
Groot
Namor
Black Bolt
Wonder Man
How well does he do against these guys out of 10? Pure H2H.
Namora
Red She-Hulk
Captain Britiain
Skaar
Ikaris
Vision