Disney vs. EU

Started by carthage3 pages
Originally posted by ares834
SWTOR is no longer canon! I love it.

👆

Honestly, I trust Disney won't commit the same stupid ass mistakes the EU writers did. Most non-PT and OT isn't canon so what? A very large amount of that was shit. Of course, there were some good parts, but they'll just make new good stuff.

Originally posted by Col. Valerian
Honestly, I trust Disney won't commit the same stupid ass mistakes the EU writers did. Most non-PT and OT isn't canon so what? A very large amount of that was shit. Of course, there were some good parts, but they'll just make new good stuff.
disney is just going to put sumbliminal messages and hidden mickeys in its Star Wars movies and tv shows, plus illuminati stuff

THe EU.U was for the greatest and the worst....
But I'm feeling than they are gonna to have some ichue with the next moovies scenario...

Originally posted by RexCloneWarsMVS
Disney sucks dick they made the EU non canon they cancelled TCW and replaced it with a disney kids show, and they are creating a not needed sequal trilogy that's what they did

'A not needed sequel trilogy'? Almost all SW stuff is not-needed!

Rebels aims to a fairly similar range as TCW, it's just earlier in the story....

Really, I'm not big into trashing the Disney canon when we have so little sampling, and what sampling we do have is fairly good.

Originally posted by Q99
'A not needed sequel trilogy'? Almost all SW stuff is not-needed!

Rebels aims to a fairly similar range as TCW, it's just earlier in the story....

Really, I'm not big into trashing the Disney canon when we have so little sampling, and what sampling we do have is fairly good.

Star Wars rebels is mostly for kids while clone wars is mostly for older viewers but it has it's childish moments (jar jar, battle droids, early ahsoka)

Well AT-AT's do have a city level feat in Empire Strikes Back.

Originally posted by RexCloneWarsMVS
Star Wars rebels is mostly for kids while clone wars is mostly for older viewers but it has it's childish moments (jar jar, battle droids, early ahsoka)

I'm going to point out how SW Rebels starts out more mature than TCW movie.

Rebels already has the parts with the Inquisitor, the Jedi trial, and similar.

And I'm certainly not going to object to new movies before they're even out.

Originally posted by Q99
I'm going to point out how SW Rebels starts out more mature than TCW movie.

Rebels already has the parts with the Inquisitor, the Jedi trial, and similar.

And I'm certainly not going to object to new movies before they're even out.

TCW movie was nothing but action. I don't get why your even referring to it and even rebels isn't more mature then it, haven't you seen all the death in that movie? Rebels has 5 or 6 deaths. No stormtroopers die. Becuase it has a jedi trial the inquisitor and "similair" doesn't make it more mature.

Originally posted by Col. Valerian
Honestly, I trust Disney won't commit the same stupid ass mistakes the EU writers did. Most non-PT and OT isn't canon so what? A very large amount of that was shit. Of course, there were some good parts, but they'll just make new good stuff.

The problem is that's a lazy job..... Because you juste have to keep the idea of a hierachical canon structure but base on some paramter like consitancy... Coherence etc etc.....

And then make some remake.. If you remake is better writted in all point it will erase the old canon.

Because what is star war? It's more than 6 ****ing moovies.

It's an universe !!!!!!!!! A place ! A timeline !

Like warhammer 40 000 ! What's warhammer? A game a serie of book? a vidéo game? NOoooooooo it's AN UNIVERSE ! AND THAT4S WHY IT'S ****ING GREAT !!!!!

Creat a moovie O.K.. Creat a moovie + a ****ing fantastic universe. I say amazing !

Originally posted by RexCloneWarsMVS
TCW movie was nothing but action. I don't get why your even referring to it and even rebels isn't more mature then it, haven't you seen all the death in that movie? Rebels has 5 or 6 deaths. No stormtroopers die. Becuase it has a jedi trial the inquisitor and "similair" doesn't make it more mature.

Peharps Rebels is more mature than TWC but that's relative.

The fact it avoid death as an heavy subject... Let's make it more childish...
Too way to abord death in a more mature content. make it less not dramatic... But not too much over dramatic to not look pretencious.. It depend of the moovie ambiance (yhea ambiance most of cineaste critic talk about character devloppement but never about the ambiance....) and who die each character or figurant have different way to die...

Or use a cold and dark black humor.....

Originally posted by Revanchiste
The problem is that's a lazy job..... Because you juste have to keep the idea of a hierachical canon structure but base on some paramter like consitancy... Coherence etc etc.....

And then make some remake.. If you remake is better writted in all point it will erase the old canon.

Because what is star war? It's more than 6 ****ing moovies.

It's an universe !!!!!!!!! A place ! A timeline !

Like warhammer 40 000 ! What's warhammer? A game a serie of book? a vidéo game? NOoooooooo it's AN UNIVERSE ! AND THAT4S WHY IT'S ****ING GREAT !!!!!

Creat a moovie O.K.. Creat a moovie + a ****ing fantastic universe. I say amazing !

Peharps Rebels is more mature than TWC but that's relative.

The fact it avoid death as an heavy subject... Let's make it more childish...
Too way to abord death in a more mature content. make it less not dramatic... But not too much over dramatic to not look pretencious.. It depend of the moovie ambiance (yhea ambiance most of cineaste critic talk about character devloppement but never about the ambiance....) and who die each character or figurant have different way to die...

Or use a cold and dark black humor.....

Star Wars rebels Is more mature then the clone wars? Your either joking or really foolish, the entire geonosis arc was more mature then any episode of rebels, and the Yoda arc from season 6 tops anything rebels throws at it storywise

Yhea why making a new trilogy when you have the E.U....
O.K if the moovie are good why not? This timeline was needed a remake... But dam keep the good stuff...
And you can make so many adaption based on the E.U !

I hate the one who say than they are happy about the E.U non canon. because it's often a rage reaction.

Because what's star war? An universe and that's pretty dam fantastic.....
Look warhammer 40 000 !!!!!!! Imagine the game without the lore and franchise... Imagine it without bolters space marines awsome epic stories.....

Star wars have that.. Especially for the old republic timeline.. And nice epic battle in the clone war.. And I really love Darth Revan story...

Having an universe is great.

This is not because you hate some category of fan or a serie than you have to be happy about it... The E.U was for the best like for the worse.....

Keep thrawn galaxy gun and the emperor rebirth.... And the academmy.. That's all what we need.......

Originally posted by RexCloneWarsMVS
Star Wars rebels Is more mature then the clone wars? Your either joking or really foolish, the entire geonosis arc was more mature then any episode of rebels, and the Yoda arc from season 6 tops anything rebels throws at it storywise

The show aren't great example both....

Originally posted by Revanchiste
Yhea why making a new trilogy when you have the E.U....
O.K if the moovie are good why not? This timeline was needed a remake... But dam keep the good stuff...
And you can make so many adaption based on the E.U !

I hate the one who say than they are happy about the E.U non canon. because it's often a rage reaction.

Because what's star war? An universe and that's pretty dam fantastic.....
Look warhammer 40 000 !!!!!!! Imagine the game without the lore and franchise... Imagine it without bolters space marines awsome epic stories.....

Star wars have that.. Especially for the old republic timeline.. And nice epic battle in the clone war.. And I really love Darth Revan story...

Having an universe is great.

This is not because you hate some category of fan or a serie than you have to be happy about it... The E.U was for the best like for the worse.....

Keep thrawn galaxy gun and the emperor rebirth.... And the academmy.. That's all what we need.......

The show aren't great example both....

what? Star Wars rebels?

Originally posted by The Merchant
Well AT-AT's do have a city level feat in Empire Strikes Back.

They do?....Must have missed it, I don't recall.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Well for one thing, it's a 80 foot tall plated hunk of metal; casually lifting and crushing one of those things is rather impressive.

Sure, its impressive

Not so much in the EU, but its a decent display of power that'd otherwise just be written off as a bit feat without Disney's current canon policy

Even working under the reasonable assumption an AT-AT can take the punishment this ship was put through? You're still looking at a feat not too out of place for the low end of high tier in terms of raw power.

The rest of your post was handled well enough by Ares

Bigger fish in a smaller pond more or less.

My bad, it was 16 Kilotons of TNT as the low-end, 3.4 Megatons as the High-end:

http://bbs.stardestroyer.net/viewtopic.php?t=10360

Depending on the forum, that could be "city level" still

Unless the Cable really had that much influence and other forums actually follow our (the OBD's) criteria :hmm

Would be cool if the images weren't dead

I'm willing to take the calc as it is, but I also come from a place that actually DOES calcs :maybe

Well, that, and I don't cling to eye balling as being anything other than a poor man's rough calc

The calculation is good.

Not doubting the math or anything

Would just like the visuals to be intact

Eh I'm not putting much stock into Calcs...but this is for mostly anything really. Although even still, the AT-AT is a pretty powerful vehicle and no doubt could level a city anyway.