Scourge vs. PoD Bane

Setting: Lehon Temple

Instead of fighting Kas'im, trainee Bane faces Scourge.

Who wins?

Bane dies.

MY 10,000TH POST YEAH

10000 posts? Jesus, you've barely been here a year...

Time flies when you're a Star wars warrior

Originally posted by carthage
Bane dies.

MY 10,000TH POST YEAH

Is this post-Revan Scourge? If so, Bane dies without too much difficulty.

Let's go with Revan Scourge.

Then I'm not sure. Bane was above practically all the One Sith even in PoD, but that's really not saying much considering they were shit. Revan Scourge was already post-KOTOR 2 Meetra level. Hmm.

Originally posted by Stigma
Let's go with Revan Scourge.

Bane.

You'd put PoD Bane above Surik?

From the book? Yes.

I think post-KOTOR 2 Surik would be better than PoD Bane, and since Revan Scourge = post-KOTOR 2 Surik, I think I'm learning towards Scourge.

That smacks of ABC to me. Scourge hasn't demonstrated that he's as skilled, fast or powerful as Bane is. I can't see him demolishing the temple, personally. And we saw his response to Nyriss and even Xedris.

To be fair, though, Nyriss >> PoD Bane. True, we've not seen much from Revan Scourge, but that doesn't mean he isn't powerful. If he's supposedly on Meetra's level, he would at least be able to give PoD Bane as good a fight as Kas'im.