Vitiate vs. Revan and HoT

Setting: Dromund Kaas.

All at their peak.

Neither gets prep time.

ROUND 2: The team is joined by peak Scourge.

Who wins?

We still don't know the peak of Vitiate or HoT but given what we know now and how it played out in the Revan book...

Round 1: HoT, unlike Exile, can battle Vitiate directly. A full powered Vitiate is too much for her, but with Revan they win with massive amounts of difficulty.

Round 2: Team wins with moderate amounts of difficulty.

What gives you the idea the Exile couldn't kill Vitiate? She could have done so through a simple lightsaber throw if she had chosen to.

He's saying that the exile would have been hilariously slaughtered if she tried to battle The Emperor directly.

Originally posted by AncientPower
What gives you the idea the Exile couldn't kill Vitiate?

Lol.

Except for the fact he would be dead if she had chosen differently. Is she on his power level? no one of the era is. Does this make him invulnerable? Hardly.

He's saying that if the exile straight up battled vitiate without catching him off guard, she's get slaughtered. Thought that was fairly obvious.

Originally posted by AncientPower
Except for the fact he would be dead if she had chosen differently. Is she on his power level? no one of the era is. Does this make him invulnerable? Hardly.

😬

He wasn't aware of her, was utterly focused on Revan and was completely off guard. What part of that says she can stand against him in a direct confrontation?

Which is irrelevant because she doesn't and didn't have to, neither did T7 as a matter of fact. My statement is correlated to the assertion that fighting Vitiate directly is a great decision maker in this battle, his own combat record says otherwise.

Hero of Python was specifically talking about the HoT being capable of directly challenging Vitiate and that the Exile couldn't. You pointing out an example of her attacking him while he's off-guard has no relevance to Python's point.

You aren't getting the part where I am wondering why that is relevant in a multi-combatant fight against 'Revan' Vitiate.

...Because in a versus forum you sorta have to assume the opponents are aware of each other...?
And we're not talking about Revan Vitiate.

Anyways, the Team takes both rounds. It's never been stated or cleared up exactly how weakened was Vitiate when he faces HoT in the JK storyline. I think Revan + HoT would be able to defeat him. Adding peak Scourge just makes the battle a little less difficult for them.

Either fighter has a chance to take out Vitiate on neutral ground. Against two there is no chance.

Oh, it is at Dromund Kaas. Well, team win anyway.

Originally posted by Hero of Python

Round 1: HoT, unlike Exile, can battle Vitiate directly.

Says who? 😕

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Says who? 😕

Says me.

But really, I don't remember all of Exiles feats in the book, but in the canon Kotor 2 story her best victories are against two beings who she is super effective against (Nihilus and Traya) and a guy who is technically immortal but has so much self doubt and inner suffering that he's convinced to end himself.

Act I HoT has better feats than that. This coming from someone who liked Kotor 2 more than 1. I usually played dark side though, and I will say that dark side Exile has far more impressive feats than her light side counterpart, such as toying with Old Republic council members.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Hero of Python was specifically talking about the HoT being capable of directly challenging Vitiate and that the Exile couldn't. You pointing out an example of her attacking him while he's off-guard has no relevance to Python's point.

Yup. I love the Exile but I don't know if she survives against Emperor's Wrath, let alone even a weakened Vitiate.

You misinterpret me. I'm saying neither of them can fight a full powered Vitiate directly.

I think they could.

No they can't.

btw, Ancient Power went full retard in this thread(no offense man) 😄

Nobody knows for certain exactly how weakened Vitiate was when HoT faced him.