Spartacus vs Maximus

Started by Jmanghan3 pages

Originally posted by Genesis-Soldier
i am with panther on this one
spartacus is a little over rated for me (thats my opinion and i am not trying to tell anyone that they are right or wrong)

maximus is more impressive with his military experience and arena fighting

You're like a flower in the middle of an Earthquake here, gens.

It doesn't matter whether or not Spartacus is overrated.

Originally posted by Dreampanther
Wow really? And did he face them unarmed and with his hands tied? Because that seems to be a lot more impressive.
So, it takes Maximus 30 seconds to kill some no-name gladiators, while Spartacus kills 4 trained soldiers with a single attack in under 5 seconds, and he's somehow better then Spartacus?

Think you've got things backwards, friend.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
So, it takes Maximus 30 seconds to kill some no-name gladiators, while Spartacus kills 4 trained soldiers with a single attack in under 5 seconds, and he's somehow better then Spartacus?

Think you've got things backwards, friend.

So, Spartacus has never faced five trained gladiators and survived, never mind killed them in thirty seconds armed with only a sword, and he has never killed four elite soldiers unarmed with his hands tied and he is somehow better than Maximus?

Think you've got things backward, friend.

What do you think Spartacus's best feat was in the arena? Since Gladiator mostly showed Maximus in the arena and didn't dwell on the twelve years he spent on the battlefield defeating army after army, gaining more than a decade of combat experience, I think it would be more fair to compare their feats in the arena.

Spartacus did pull a John Preston:

YouTube video

@ 00:16

Originally posted by Robtard
Spartacus did pull a John Preston:

YouTube video

@ 00:16

Lol. I like this one @ 01:12

YouTube video

Any opinions changed? Bump.

Jokes aside, Spartacus has a lot more feats that show he's the superior warrior. We're talking an almost 3 hour movie vs 30ish hours of TV time, which was heavy on the stylized action.

Spartacus stomps; hes stronger (chops body parts off like butter) and better trained (his training with doctore alone is better than anything that Maximus endures)

Yeah, after watching the whole series, I would say Spartacus destroys him.

Theokoles killed 100 men in the arena and even without help, was able to last against him for a considerable amount of time.

On type of that, he made The Egyptian look like a child holding a sword, keep in mind, this is the same Egyptian that killed Oenomaus, and was beating Crixus.

Spartacus surpassed most of the others in skill LONG ago, with only Gannicus to be able to rival him.

Spartacus with slight difficulty

I do think Maximus will give a good fight, though.

Originally posted by juggerman
I think Spatacus got better than Crixus in the end. But he never surpassed Oenomaus imo
This is old but he absolutely surpassed Oenomaus, who had his shit pushed in by The Egyptian. Spartacus whooped the Egyptian's ass in like 10 seconds:
YouTube video

Gladiator is one of my favorite movies and Maximus is a solid fighter, but Spartacus (I assume from the TV show?) has lots and lots and lots more feats. He'd take this 10 out of 10.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
This is old but he absolutely surpassed Oenomaus, who had his shit pushed in by The Egyptian. Spartacus whooped the Egyptian's ass in like 10 seconds:
YouTube video

Spartacus and Gannicus where the two top fighters in the show, virtually equals.

I haven't seen Spartacus so I don't know who wins. But I'll offer some advice. Look carefully at a character's reflexes, ability to defend and counter, stamina, speed, strength (only if there is a big difference), size and weight, and agility.

Both have fought armies of men from what I know. Both have fought trained fighters. I would have to analyze the fights to determine a winner. Need to see how well Spartacus can defend and counter, his reflexes, speed, and stamina. I know a good deal about fighting and base my decision on those attributes (abc logic is even flawed in real life mma fights).