KMC: CBVF Members POWER RANKINGS

Started by Galan0078 pages

Originally posted by Branlor Swift
😂

On the thread...

Carver is at the top. Everyone else is divided among how many fractions of a Carve they have.

Street level - 0.00 - 0.10 Carves

Metahuman - 0.11 - 0.25 Carves

Low Herald - 0.26 - 0.50 Carves

Mid Herald - 0.51 - 0.75 Carves

High Herald - 0.76 - 0.95 Carves

It only goes up to .95 Carves because no one is possibly within .04 Carves of equalling a whole Carve, except the man himself. Although I'd imagine Carver could surpass a full Carve if he quickquoted himself a couple times.

At least that's how I'd rank it.

You know how to get carver rock-f*cking-hard.

Originally posted by Blair Wind
BSwift, rank a few people. I need more data to be able to extrapolate exactly how the Carver Scale can be appropriately applied.
Boardwalker is about a .01, maybe a .02
H1 is a .08. 0.11 being his max

Those are probably the worst ones. H1 wouldn't be so low if he wasn't wrong 100 percent of the time

Higher end ones would be leo and galan who are probably hovering around 0.85-ish. Sometimes leo just does leo stuff and goes down a couple though. Wonder Woman/BA for example.

I'd probably put celey (name just popped up in my brain) at .70-ish

It's really all about quality. Everyone strives to be the best, but even the best isn't good enough unless you're the namesake. You don't have to follow in Carver's footsteps, you just gotta be able to put right ideas into words. Anything low herald and above would show a functioning brain and working knowledge of comics though at least to some degree.

If that gives you an idea.

BW thinks he's Cosmic Armor Superman, though. Does that bump him up on the carvometer at all?

Originally posted by Galan007
BW thinks he's Cosmic Armor Superman, though. Does that bump him up on the carvometer at all?

At first I thought you were talking about me. How ****ing arrogant do you think I am?

Then I realized you meant Board Walker. 👆

You're the runner-up BW. 👆

Originally posted by Galan007
BW thinks he's Cosmic Armor Superman, though. Does that bump him up on the carvometer at all?
0.00

Originally posted by Galan007
You're the runner-up BW. 👆

😠 There can only be one. Board Walker's getting sent an assassin.

Originally posted by Branlor Swift
Higher end ones would be leo and galan who are probably hovering around 0.85-ish. Sometimes leo just does leo stuff and goes down a couple though. Wonder Woman/BA for example.

I'm curious as to where Digi, Delph, Darthgoober, Id, Smurph, and I all end up on the scale without self reporting - can't place yourself into a tier, imo.

I therefore propose we adopt said carvescale for KMC member tiering and that Branlor be put in charge of preliminary ratings within said scale!

Originally posted by Galan007
BW thinks he's Cosmic Armor Superman, though. Does that bump him up on the carvometer at all?
That puts him in the negative range.

Bran, your math is flawless. You're making Assnerd look like a second-rate pretender right now. 👆

Originally posted by Blair Wind
😠 There can only be one. Board Walker's getting sent an assassin.

I'm curious as to where Digi, Delph, Darthgoober, Id, Smurph, and I all end up on the scale without self reporting - can't place yourself into a tier, imo.

I don't really look at the bz forum like ever but it's a pretty safe bet it goes mid to high for most. Especially since the Carve scale is based on a single post basis and that would be the place you're trying to make every one count.

Also I'd like to see the man himself rank his underlings tbh. I'm pretty much adapting it for everything from now on personally.

Originally posted by Nibedicus
I therefore propose we adopt said carvescale for KMC member tiering and that Branlor be put in charge of preliminary ratings within said scale!

You foreigners can use the Carver scale, here in America we need something else!

Originally posted by Galan007
Bran, your math is flawless. You're making Assnerd look like a second-rate pretender right now. 👆

The show?

Originally posted by Branlor Swift
😂

On the thread...

Carver is at the top. Everyone else is divided among how many fractions of a Carve they have.

Street level - 0.00 - 0.10 Carves

Metahuman - 0.11 - 0.25 Carves

Low Herald - 0.26 - 0.50 Carves

Mid Herald - 0.51 - 0.75 Carves

High Herald - 0.76 - 0.95 Carves

It only goes up to .95 Carves because no one is possibly within .04 Carves of equalling a whole Carve, except the man himself. Although I'd imagine Carver could surpass a full Carve if he quickquoted himself a couple times.

At least that's how I'd rank it.


😂

Originally posted by Branlor Swift
It's the only proper way to measure being right on a post by post basis.

Sometimes not even Carver can hit a full Carve. But when he puts everything into it, it's the ceiling

Are you saying Carver subconsciously hold back?

Bran Bran Bran can you rate me!? Rate me, need attention!

Originally posted by Branlor Swift
Higher end ones would be leo and galan who are probably hovering around 0.85-ish. Sometimes leo just does leo stuff and goes down a couple though

hrm. it's part of my charm. sneer

and if this galan kid is as good as you say, i may need to take him off ignore. mmm

Originally posted by mamaguebaso

Bran can you rate me!?


A bold request from BW's biggest fan and supporter.

Originally posted by Branlor Swift
Boardwalker is about a .01, maybe a .02
H1 is a .08. 0.11 being his max

Those are probably the worst ones. H1 wouldn't be so low if he wasn't wrong 100 percent of the time

Higher end ones would be leo and galan who are probably hovering around 0.85-ish. Sometimes leo just does leo stuff and goes down a couple though. Wonder Woman/BA for example.

I'd probably put celey (name just popped up in my brain) at .70-ish

It's really all about quality. Everyone strives to be the best, but even the best isn't good enough unless you're the namesake. You don't have to follow in Carver's footsteps, you just gotta be able to put right ideas into words. Anything low herald and above would show a functioning brain and working knowledge of comics though at least to some degree.

If that gives you an idea.


Mid herald.. Hmm....

Obviously this ranking is based upon the influence that specific posters have upon the homeostasis, and the alteration of the forum environment.

In that case the posters that would rank the highest are those who generate the largest responses from others on a consistent basis, those users would be individuals like LoB, Quanchi, that dracula poster, H1, Prof.TC., Nvrbnwthagrl, swirly, etc.

Posters such as Galan, Mr. Master, and many others would be very low on this scale as their influence is minimal at changing the pre existing paradigm of the forum. Their function is to primarily add to what was established by others long ago, in other words easily replaceable and of less value due to their available quantity on the market.

More accurately what this thread is doing is not ranking posters on a vertical scale of low to high, but rather placing posters on a horizontal spectrum of paradigm difference. You will find that that those who think alike will all tend to end up on one side relatively closely, while those they see as being entirely different will be placed opposite of them (on the low side). Yet this scale has noway of objectively measuring value in its current incarnation, the dependent variable has not been set nor does it any an independent variable to contrast it.

An example of an objective ranking would be to measure the value of a poster by the number of posts that can illicit when they make a posts. The number of posts they generate from others on average can then be converted to a currency amount, based upon a forecasted number of adds viewed per poster in response to the original posters post (Dependent variable).

Ultimately this forum at its most barest function is a testing ground for personality shards, and for others to live out archtypes of their own self in a digilital fashion they would unotherwise be able to in a tangible setting consistently.