The Exile vs. Obi Wan ROTS

Started by carthage2 pages

The Exile vs. Obi Wan ROTS

PRIME VERSIONS OF BOTH CHARACTERS

BATTLE TAKES PLACE ON RAXUS PRIME

The Exile.

Exile. Mid difficulty at most.

Good fight.

Following characteristics define the Exile:

1. Great lightsaber combat skills
2. One of the most resolute Jedi
3. Powerful in the ways of the Force

IMO, the Exile might be capable of defeating Obi-Wan in some settings. At minimum, achieve stalemate.

Well, I doubt the Exile is actually more skilled than Obi-Wan as a combatant, but she has greater instinctive skill and she's more versatile/adaptable, not to mention her various Force Forms and just greater Force power. In her absolute prime, she'd win in an extremely good bout.

Kenobi comfortably.

Had you asked me in 2005 I'd say Exile, but nowadays I'd lean towards Kenobi having the edge.

Prime Exile is dark side ending version, right?

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Kenobi comfortably.

You dissapoint me.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Kenobi comfortably.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Kenobi comfortably.

Based on?

Kenobi.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Kenobi comfortably.

These two are pretty even, tbh.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Kenobi comfortably.

👆

Originally posted by Hero of Python
Had you asked me in 2005 I'd say Exile, but nowadays I'd lean towards Kenobi having the edge.

Wait....So you live in Poughkeepsie New York?

Anyone care to provide any reasoning?

Surik's mastered all forms of lightsaber combat. Kenobi has mastered two. While I'm happy to admit his Soresu is far more prominent than hers, it doesn't matter. Frankly he lacks the offensive ability to break her defenses, since even Atris (A master of Juyo) could not. She on the other hand can break his, and she has outrageous stamina if she needs to take him down.

We've seen multiple times in his duels with Maul that physical attacks are one of his weaknesses. Someone who can take out powerful dark jedi with her bare hands isn't a mook when it comes to physical blows. She's also mastered the Echani styles and can use precognition against him.

She also has intricate knowledge on his forms where he has little on hers, and can even learn from him as he fights.

In terms of force power, she simply outclasses him. The guy who's ragdolled by Dooku, vs the woman who faced down Traya in the galaxies greatest dark side nexus and won.

She's his better in every single way, deal with it.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Kenobi comfortably.

Obi is more skilled and more powerful in the force

*sits back and waits for the backlash*

Agreed.