Has there ever been an argument between 2 mods about banning a member?

As the title says.

Or maybe closing a thread?

Probably plenty, but in private. Pretty sure there's a mods-only section we can't see (obviously).

If the mod team has a discussion about banned members, we do it in the Moderator's Lounge and not in public.

Moderator's Lounge sounds fun, but when I was a mod it was all boring. 😛

They serve beer?

Originally posted by Stringer
They serve beer?

Non-alcoholic. 😠

Guess its byob

Originally posted by Impediment
If the mod team has a discussion about banned members, we do it in the Moderator's Lounge and not in public.

Like, never a mishap where you let bias get in the way or something?

When one notorious member was banned for something he didn't do, we had a lengthy discussion with each other about it.

Notorious. That sounds like a big deal.

Was it king???

Originally posted by Jmanghan
As the title says.

Or maybe closing a thread?

Originally posted by rudester
Was it king???

Probably AC. Paola banned him for trolling a Hit Girl vs. thread. Some people didn't see it as trolling. But his opening line in that vs. thread was something to the effect of all the Hit Girl fans sucking her dick too much...which is like...classic internet trolling 101. 😐

Go into a thread where clearly the majority of opinions supports idea A.

Then tell everyone that they are sucking the dick of idea A. Watch people b*tch. Continue goading. Enjoy trolling.

Why some mods disagreed with Paola, I have no idea. But Paola said she was given shit over it. She was tired of his (AC's) bullshit and decided to axe it right then and there.

That's the only time I am aware of mod disagreement. And that disagreement was in private until they worked it out. Clearly, AC's ban was permanent so they worked out their disagreement.

Also, when Rogue Jedi was banned by Backfire, Backfire said it was one of he easiest modding decisions he made. Despite the disagreement of many members with that decision, I don't think the mods disagreed at all on that one (he made an indirect jab at a KMC member...it was waaaaaaaay below the belt. Absurdly so. I warned RJ about trying to make that jab and even convinced him to edit it out of a previous post).

Also, when Chillmeistergen was permabanned by WanderingDroid (WrathfulDwarf), some members b*tched. However, Chill was very...uh...he insulted people quite often. haha He deserved his ban.

Those are the only real "controversial" permabans I can think of.

How do you remember all of that?

AC's days were numbered, I agree, and his eventual banishment was inevitable, but he did nothing to deserve the pem ban he received.

Inevitable banishment. Heavy.

Man, that's throwing it way back.

I don't think I ever disagreed with anyone on a banning. I had one very active member in the SWVs. that I wasn't sure was a sock, but he pinged on our sock checker.

Now I don't really wander out of the SWRP area so... shrug?

Originally posted by riv6672
How do you remember all of that?

My mind is great for school but bad for getting over exes.

😐

Originally posted by Impediment
AC's days were numbered, I agree, and his eventual banishment was inevitable, but he did nothing to deserve the pem ban he received.

Blah, you know I love you so I'll just leave it be. Some topics are not worth being pissy with loved ones :*