Replace Captain America???

again AND? Who cares Silent. you already made the point.. he clarified and further clarified he didn't want them to be old as well. That is basic common sense... He doesn't need to clarify that part it should be obvious. Regardless, that doesn't explain why you keep bringing it up. He didn't want that part included which is understandable. Who cares if they could survive being in snow for years. I mean really, who cares. It's understandable he wouldn't want that included nor that he'd want them 90. Why is this so difficult for you to grasp. We get it, you made the point, he clarified.. this should be the end of it.

Everyone...the Ice scene isn't included in this thread. Please ignore Silent.

Only these 4 have a shot

Blade
Khan
Wolverine
Ozy

Since carter has already admitted that most of the people would have died in the first movie, we can move on and say that most of them wouldn't survive jumping from the plane in WS.

They all wouldn't be able to get out of the rubble after Zola blows up the secret base.

But im guessing carver will say , "thats not what i meant."
So i dont know what the fuq this thread is about 😬

Originally posted by Silent Master
Since carter has already admitted that most of the people would have died in the first movie, we can move on and say that most of them wouldn't survive jumping from the plane in WS.

Blade, Khan and Wolverine would. Ozy, I wanna say yes but idk for sure

Originally posted by juggerman
Blade, Khan and Wolverine would. Ozy, I wanna say yes but idk for sure

With the possible exception of Khan all the ones you listed would at least be ko'd.

Originally posted by Inhuman
They all wouldn't be able to get out of the rubble after Zola blows up the secret base.

But im guessing carver will say , "thats not what i meant."
So i dont know what the fuq this thread is about 😬

Its a thread that has been done before. OP didn't care to search for it.

Really it seems aimed at lowballing Cap's feats because Carver has argued many of these char's that would take cap in a fight, and he lost those debates..so this is "revenge."

Originally posted by Inhuman
They all wouldn't be able to get out of the rubble after Zola blows up the secret base.

But im guessing carver will say , "thats not what i meant."
So i dont know what the fuq this thread is about 😬

They would probably get out of that situation the same way Cap did.

Most would die jumping from the plane in WS.

Originally posted by Silent Master
With the possible exception of Khan all the ones you listed would at least be ko'd.

But they would survive.

Originally posted by carver9
They would probably get out of that situation the same way Cap did.

By lifting a beam and rubble that probably weighed a few tons?

Dont think so.

Originally posted by juggerman
But they would survive.

The terms of the OP state that they have to match or exceed Cap's performance, so them being ko'd means they fail.

Originally posted by Silent Master
The terms of the OP state that they have to match or exceed Cap's performance, so them being ko'd means they fail.

Good point.

But they don't have to do it exactly like him. IOW they could defeat Bucky and not go down with the ship.

Originally posted by juggerman
Good point.

But they don't have to do it exactly like him. IOW they could defeat Bucky and not go down with the ship.

I'm talking about the start of the movie where Cap, BW and the commandos attack Batroc and the other mercs and since the OP states that they have to match or exceed his performance, that means they can't use a chute.

In Silent attempts to trash this thread because its' Carver.. he didn't read the OP thread closely. Just because they can't accomplish a particular feat doesn't mean the rest are null and void. He specifically says, list the feats they can or can't do and why. He's already acknowledged that they might not be able to accomplish some but want to know which ones they can or can't. Thus, just because they can't accomplish the ice feat.. doesn't mean we stop examining there. So not only is this crusade pointless as it defies logic and has already been clarified, but they don't have to accomplish them all in order to list what can or can't be done by each.

Originally posted by Silent Master
I'm talking about the start of the movie where Cap, BW and the commandos attack Batroc and the other mercs and since the OP states that they have to match or exceed his performance, that means they can't use a chute.

OOOOOOHHHHHHHHHH

Yeah that was pretty boss. Didn't Logan do it in Origins? Not sure if Blade has anything like that. Ozy doesn't

Originally posted by juggerman
OOOOOOHHHHHHHHHH

Yeah that was pretty boss. Didn't Logan do it in Origins? Not sure if Blade has anything like that. Ozy doesn't

Don't remember, the only parts of that movie I paid any attention too were the Deadpool scenes.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Don't remember, the only parts of that movie I paid any attention too were the Deadpool scenes.

Just looked it up. He was trying to get on the island to save the mutants and kill Creed. Gambit was flying the plane and he jumped out. He didn't have a gentle splash like Cap either. He was like a rocked being skipped

Originally posted by juggerman
Just looked it up. He was trying to get on the island to save the mutants and kill Creed. Gambit was flying the plane and he jumped out. He didn't have a gentle splash like Cap either. He was like a rocked being skipped

That was adamantium version though.