Maestro vs Green Scar

Originally posted by Hyperion Prime
I think Maestro wins. More experience and would he not have one point in time have been the Green Scar?

No.

He's from an alternate reality, WWH might not have even happened there. And even if it did, nothing suggests he kept WWH power levels.

Trying to figure out why people are giving Maestro the win against Greenscar. Are they just doing that because his name sounds nice because it can't be based entirely off of fts.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
No.

He's from an alternate reality, WWH might not have even happened there. And even if it did, nothing suggests he kept WWH power levels.

I see what you are saying. I always though Maestro was from the 616 future and not an alternate reality. They are not really clear on it.

In Future Imperfect, I dont believe Hulk went to another reality, more traveling to the future, meeting his future self as Maestro, so youd figure it would be future 616 Hulk. Obviously theres no mention of WWHulk in Future Imperfect, as those series of stories (Planet Hulk, WWHulk, etc) werent actually written yet, and not yet part of the Hulks history.

Originally posted by DTM
In Future Imperfect, I dont believe Hulk went to another reality, more traveling to the future, meeting his future self as Maestro, so youd figure it would be future 616 Hulk.

Thanks for clearing that up. That is why I was saying at one point Maestro was the Green Scar. If that is the case I don't see how he loses to the Green Scar if they don't throw in any PIS/CIS. Maestro beat Hulk by breaking his neck. He knows Hulks weak points. He has the strength to beat Scar. I really do think that eventually in 616 Banner will become Maestro. It may take 30 years, but Marvel will do it.

Originally posted by Hyperion Prime
Thanks for clearing that up. That is why I was saying at one point Maestro was the Green Scar. If that is the case I don't see how he loses to the Green Scar if they don't throw in any PIS/CIS. Maestro beat Hulk by breaking his neck. He knows Hulks weak points. He has the strength to beat Scar. I really do think that eventually in 616 Banner will become Maestro. It may take 30 years, but Marvel will do it.

No they weren't the same person. Maestro assured Merged Hulk that if he were to kill himself that he would continue to live on with or without him. 616 did not affect Maestro whatsoever. There was no mention of Maestro having a wife named Caiera either, or a son named Skaar, and Lyrra is never mentioned either. We never see Maestro amplify his power except when he raged out. This is something that the Green Scar didn't have to do. he could mentally increase his stats without going berserk as mentioned during the Planet Hulk arc when he underwent meditation to improve himself.

Maestro is not the future version of 616 Hulk in any way, or he would have never told Merged Hulk what he did concerning suicide. Maestro is not set in stone, hence the title Future Imperfect. Maestro would be a good match for War Hulk, but not so much for the Green Scar.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
In the off-topic thread.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=362941&pagenumber=13161

Originally posted by DTM
In Future Imperfect, I dont believe Hulk went to another reality, more traveling to the future, meeting his future self as Maestro, so youd figure it would be future 616 Hulk. Obviously theres no mention of WWHulk in Future Imperfect, as those series of stories (Planet Hulk, WWHulk, etc) werent actually written yet, and not yet part of the Hulks history.

It is another reality. Earth-9200.

http://marvel.wikia.com/Incredible_Hulk:_Future_Imperfect_Vol_1_1

Like Cable once said - there are many futures, not just one... many different worlds.