Poll
43%
57%
Originally posted by RobtardWhat does this have to do with which is more powerful. Do you not understand the words, which is more powerful ?
-Death Star can destroy a planet with a single blast from a great distance.-Red Matter has to be drilled down into a planet's core and then deployed that way. (though I do question this, we go off showings)
So when it comes to destroying a planet, the Death Star is more convenient and safer.
Originally posted by RobtardYou went onto tell us what is more practical or more convenient which doesn't address the point of the topic at all. Which is more powerful the Death Star or red matter ? That's the point. What's your answer ?
I clearly addressed the thread on point, you're just trying to turn everything into a flame war as per your MO, because you can't intelligently and calmly debate your position. Everyone knows this about you. So best of luck baiting.
Define "powerful". In what aspect and context, I mean.
The Death Star has the ability to destroy an entire planet and has millions of personal that can pilot anything from TIE Fighters to Star Destroyers. Also, those who aren't combat personnel are highly skilled tacticians and scientists who employ vast amounts of knowledge for military conquest.
Red Matter, when activated, creates a black hole that can vary in size depending on the amount of Red Matter used.
I don't know how this is a versus match. You're simply looking for opinions.
Originally posted by ImpedimentIt is a versus matchup in terms of greater offensive power. That's how I define more powerful here. I am basing my opinion off feats. I can tell you what I think based off which feats if you want to know.
Define "powerful". In what aspect and context, I mean.The Death Star has the ability to destroy an entire planet and has millions of personal that can pilot anything from TIE Fighters to Star Destroyers. Also, those who aren't combat personnel are highly skilled tacticians and scientists who employ vast amounts of knowledge for military conquest.
Red Matter, when activated, creates a black hole that can vary in size depending on the amount of Red Matter used.
I don't know how this is a versus match. You're simply looking for opinions.
Originally posted by quanchi112
No, I just have my own opinion but am willing to listen others. I'm very open minded. What's your opinion ?
Everybody already knows your opinion. it's as obvious as this:
That said, I think the Death Star and DS2 have the advantage. Don't misunderstand, the ability to create temporary black holes is nice, but the ability to instapop a planet, through planetary shields, from a considerable distance, is simply too much. A torpedo with a red matter warhead, or a bomb of the stuff using transporters is too easily screwed with.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Ps. You should lighten up.
Well, can you at least be sensible?
Originally posted by Darkstorm ZeroThis is about offensive output not what is more effective in combat. I also disagree with you there.
Everybody already knows your opinion. it's as obvious as this:That said, I think the Death Star and DS2 have the advantage. Don't misunderstand, the ability to create temporary black holes is nice, but the ability to instapop a planet, through planetary shields, from a considerable distance, is simply too much. A torpedo with a red matter warhead, or a bomb of the stuff using transporters is too easily screwed with.
Well, can you at least be sensible?
You can control a space better with a deathstar. and allow the planet to function rather than holding a black hole over their heads, and if they call your bluff..a planet is gone, waste for everyone.
Deathstar is the better tool, but red matter can destroy a deathstar so its more powerful, more raw power anyway.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Wrong. Death Star destroyed a planet but the red matters greatest feat was a star that went super nova.
Wrong. it was theorised by Spock Prime that he could use it to neutralise a Supernova, but he failed. We see only 2 detonations of the red matter, and neither one consumed a Star.