TPM Darth Maul vs. ROTJ Darth Vader (sabers only)

Round 1: Canon feats only

Round 2: EU feats

*Sabers only

Battle takes place on the Golden gate bridge

"What could you possibly hate enough to destroy me?"
"Myself"

Vader wins, close fight.

-

By RotJ, Vader should be above Maul.

Round 1 should be the same as the comic fight.

Round 2 is closer and more or less even between the two.

Round 1: Maul, tbh.
Round 2: Probably Vader.

Originally posted by |King Joker|
By RotJ, Vader should be above Maul.

Maul.

Maul in a close fight

Originally posted by ILS
Sabers only? y

He's supposed to have significantly improved his swordplay between his battle with that Maul duplicate and RotJ.

That said I dunno if that story is even possible anymore.

Originally posted by Nephthys
He's supposed to have significantly improved his swordplay between his battle with that Maul duplicate and RotJ.

Well not in canon. Rebels Vader has been stated as Vader in his prime.

Originally posted by Nephthys
That said I dunno if that story is even possible anymore.

Well not in Canon, no.

But then Legends acknowledges TCW, so that story would be problematic fitting into Legends even.

Originally posted by Nephthys
He's supposed to have significantly improved his swordplay between his battle with that Maul duplicate and RotJ.

That said I dunno if that story is even possible anymore.

Originally posted by ILS
Sure, but Maul pretty cleanly won that fight.

Well he was wining until Vader stabbed himself to kill "Maul".