ANH Darth Vader vs. Qui Gon Jinn

*Film feats only

Force, sabers, all out

Battle takes place on neutral ground

Vadar

Vader destroys

Vader, Qui Gonn couldn't even beat Maul

Movie feats only. If you're the type of person that can watch Vaders martial arts performance in the original trilogy and think his sabre display even holds a candle to any prominent sabre user in the later trilogy, then you're insane and EU feats have clouded you. Now you're going to cry about the time era the movies were made and how martial arts hadn't heavily influenced the choreography blah blah. Maul would stomp movie Vader and Luke, even together. They sucked at fighting.

Vader. Shouldn't this be in the Star Wars versus forum?

Vader all the way.

Originally posted by Juk3n
Movie feats only. If you're the type of person that can watch Vaders martial arts performance in the original trilogy and think his sabre display even holds a candle to any prominent sabre user in the later trilogy, then you're insane and EU feats have clouded you. Now you're going to cry about the time era the movies were made and how martial arts hadn't heavily influenced the choreography blah blah. Maul would stomp movie Vader and Luke, even together. They sucked at fighting.

Your opinion.

Vader. Easily.

Vader wins. Not a stomp though.

Id go with Vader as well, just stronger in the Force IMO, but Qui Gonn (who is actually a Jedi Master) would put up a good showing in the end.