Originally posted by Darth Abonis
I said Anakin potential.
Oh, i thought that was just your list lol, in that case Annie would be above Yoda, yeah.
Originally posted by Darth Abonis
Adi got stomped by the skilless Savage Opress and Luminara couldn't deal with Asajj.
Not really. Adi did pretty well against Opress' power attacks and it's especially impressive since she was only using one-handed strikes. Lumi's confirmed to have stalemated Ventress via the Ultimate Star Wars sourcebook.
And if you wanna talk technicalities, I don't see how beating a disadvantaged Grievous is that impressive lol. But either way i have Kit there.
Originally posted by Selenial
Your list really broke down in this section, not gonna lie.
because of Shaak being on Even level? well that's because she doesn't really have much in new canon Sel. If memory serves me right, she just TK'ed a couple of droids and blocked blaster fire.
I was only basing it on Canon feats, nothing from legends.
Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
because of Shaak being on Even level? well that's because she doesn't really have much in new canon Sel. If memory serves me right, she just TK'ed a couple of droids and blocked blaster fire.I was only basing it on Canon feats, nothing from legends.
Oh not just Shaak Ti, every tier in that part 😛
Although, regarding Shaak Ti. Depends how you interpret the Novels being canon or not, but being called the most cunning Jedi in the order, one of the order's great Swordmasters and one of the greatest warriors of the order is better than what Ahsoka has 😮
Originally posted by Selenial
Oh not just Shaak Ti, every tier in that part 😛
Damn, i thought it was decent.
Although, regarding Shaak Ti. Depends how you interpret the Novels being canon or not, but being called the most cunning Jedi in the order, one of the order's great Swordmasters and one of the greatest warriors of the order is better than what Ahsoka has 😮
:mmm: I forgot about the novels. Okay, what would you fix? lemme know via PM or on here.
Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
Damn, i thought it was decent.:mmm: I forgot about the novels. Okay, what would you fix? lemme know via PM or on here.
Shaak Ti/Kit Fisto/Luminara
Plo Koon/ Depa Bilaba
Ki-Adi/Aayla Secura
Ahsoka
Even Piell
That'd be my list, honestly. Remember that Depa was also stated to be one of the top Swordbeings of the Jedi Order... There's also statements about the Jedi Council in general that put Ki Adi above Ahsoka, namely that they're 12 of the most powerful and skilled Jedi in the order, something Ahsoka is not.
I'm kinda guessing about Aayla though.
Originally posted by Selenial
Shaak Ti/Kit Fisto/LuminaraPlo Koon/ Depa Bilaba
Ki-Adi/Aayla Secura
Ahsoka
Even Piell
Where's Adi 🙁
That'd be my list, honestly. Remember that Depa was also stated to be one of the top Swordbeings of the Jedi Order... There's also statements about the Jedi Council in general that put Ki Adi above Ahsoka, namely that they're 12 of the most powerful and skilled Jedi in the order, something Ahsoka is not.
There should probably be something in the databanks and USW that showcases his power.
Great list though.
Originally posted by Selenial
If it makes you feel better, I thought everything else was spot on, and it's not that far off mine 😛
Awesome! Thanks for taking the time to do the list and explain your reasoning 😄