Team 1 pretty easily.
Everyone on team 2 is mid meta tops, vixen and Blue beetle are at least high meta and Aquaman DCNu is rated as low herald.
How is this even fair?
Vixen can be strongerr, faster and have greater durability and healing thsn the entire team 2 combined. Beetle can take on Lanterns. Aquaman has hurt Darksied with his trident and is pretty high durability wise. Add in the amp of Nth metal that can for a complete suit of armor around Karter and I dont see how team 2 hurts anyone but E2 hawkgirl.