It's hard to say because Dooku and a,cd are thought to be equals. Mace has a more kinetic fighting style so Anakin can't just use his brutal offense to take down windu. Also if he taps into the dark side mace can use that against him,a mad also he could penetrate kenobis defense if he had to.
I say windu.
Originally posted by Darth Thor
Well he's never managed to overpower Dooku in a force contest. But he managed to overpower Dooku in a Saber contest. And I don't think Windu is head and shoulders above Dooku in any area.
That could be due to Dookus weakness to kinetic attacks. Windu doesn't have that big of a weakness and has vaapad so if he taps into that dark side power it works against him. So while I agree that he isn't just better than Dooku I actually think Dooku is slightly better however not my much.
Originally posted by Darth Thor
Well he's never managed to overpower Dooku in a force contest.
Welp, Dooku's stronger than Mace in the Force. Not to mention, LoE wasn't a direct contest, but Anakin really scared the Count's socks off there.
But he managed to overpower Dooku in a Saber contest. And I don't think Windu is head and shoulders above Dooku in any area.
Dooku faltered under Anakin's aggression; Mace would probably capitalize on it. Though that doesn't necessarily mean he'll win either.
Originally posted by NewGuy01
Welp, Dooku's stronger than Mace in the Force.
He probably has the edge, and certainly seems to apply it better in combat. But there's clearly not a massive difference between their Raw Power in Telekinesis.
Originally posted by NewGuy01
Not to mention, LoE wasn't a direct contest, but Anakin really scared the Count's socks off there.
Yeah Anakin has Amazing One-Off showings like that, and like him Controlling the Son and Daughter.
But, it's not something he seems to have proper and full control over, so that he can apply it in combat on a consistent basis and in a reliable manner.
Originally posted by NewGuy01
Dooku faltered under Anakin's aggression; Mace would probably capitalize on it. Though that doesn't necessarily mean he'll win either.
Never said otherwise. I just think Anakin has a much better shot in a Saber contest than in a Tk contest against someone of Mace's caliber (at least on a consistent basis).
Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
That could be due to Dookus weakness to kinetic attacks. Windu doesn't have that big of a weakness and has vaapad so if he taps into that dark side power it works against him. So while I agree that he isn't just better than Dooku I actually think Dooku is slightly better however not my much.
I've never bought Dooku's "weakness" to kinetic attacks. In fact the word "Weakness" was never even mentioned in regards to that. It was actually Djem So's lack of mobility which was mentioned as a "weakness" Dooku could exploit in the same passage.
Originally posted by Darth Thor
I've never bought Dooku's "weakness" to kinetic attacks
Good, because it's Stover's BS. In the novel Dooku was overhelmed by Anakin's kinetic power and he actually wasn't even able to block Anakin's blows. BS, since he could do that in the movie. More then that, he could block Anakin and Obi-Wan's blows at once.
Ayway, I'm wondering - will Kenobi be conscious/alive at the end of this fight?
Originally posted by McP
Good, because it's Stover's BS. In the novel Dooku was overhelmed by Anakin's kinetic power and he actually wasn't even able to block Anakin's blows. BS, since he could do that in the movie. More then that, he could block Anakin and Obi-Wan's blows at once.
I doubt Stover meant for that statement of his to lowball Dooku so much.
He never said "The Power of Djem So is too much for Makashi," or that "Anakin's Strength is Dooku's Great Weakness."
He said Makashi isn't suited to tackle Djem So head-to-head, especially while fending off a second attacker.
Originally posted by McP
Ayway, I'm wondering - will Kenobi be conscious/alive at the end of this fight?
Against Windu with Skywalker as back up? I'm guessing he'll be around to see the end of the fight.
Windu's as Powerful as Dooku but not as skilled in his force usage or in his combo attacks IMHO.