Anakin vs. Thrawn Luke

I've estimated this to be the closest thing to a balance point between Father and Son. Before this, Anakin shouldn't have a problem. After this is DE, and Luke surpasses his father rather badly.

Round 2: Swap Anakin out for ROTJ Vader. And this time Vader isn't halfassing the fight like he does in redemption mode.

Originally posted by Angelalex242
I've estimated this to be the closest thing to a balance point between Father and Son. After this is DE, and Luke surpasses his father rather badly.

Nah on both fronts.

Anakin wins.

What? When did everyone's opinion of DE Luke take such a nosedive?

DE Luke beats Anakin, but he hasn't surpassed him as much as you think. He wouldn't stomp him by any means.

They also both lose to Plagueis, which isn't a bad thing, although I forgot how much you shit on Plagueis' lightsaber skill.

Round 1: Anakin

Round 2: Luke in a decent fight due to an increase in force power.