Darty Sidious vs Darth Caedus and Jaina Solo

How does each version of Sidious fair.

ROTS version
Sabers-
Force-
All out-

ROTJ
Sabers
Force-
All out

DE
sabers
Force
All out

All battles take place on neutral ground.
Sidious gets two sabers.
Can the twins defeat Sidious in any of his forms.

click edit, then advance setting, then you can change the title of this bud.

Sidious gets slaughtered in Round 1, wins in ROTJ, wins solidly in DE

I think the twins could possibly take ROTJ as well with BM.

Lose to DE, though.

Two on one, I give the twins a solid win in all three scenarios.

The twins take sabers only in a difficult fight. The other ones, I could see Sidious removing Jaina with the Force to dispose of Caedus.

It should be the same for all versions of Sidious.

Originally posted by carthage
Sidious gets slaughtered in Round 1, wins in ROTJ, wins solidly in DE

Lol wut? ROTS Sidious and ROTJ Sidious are not that far apart that he goes from getting low diffed to winning mid-diff.

Originally posted by SunRazer
The twins take sabers only in a difficult fight. The other ones, I could see Sidious removing Jaina with the Force to dispose of Caedus.

It should be the same for all versions of Sidious.

Probably, yeah.

Caedus by himself is superior to DE Sidious, adding his sister makes this an absolute stomp due to battle meld and force sever.

Sidious loses sabers, in the other rounds he throws Jaina at a wall and then kills Caedus.

My views.

ROTS sidious would lose. Caedus isn't that far off from sidious and then add his sister I would say they can take sabers force and all out.

ROTJ sidious. I'm not sure about sabers but sidious wins everything else.

DE sidious wins all.

I don't think DE Sidious is any better in sabers than RotJ, just force.

And two on one makes things very hard, especially against ones of this level.

Originally posted by SunRazer
The twins take sabers only in a difficult fight. The other ones, I could see Sidious removing Jaina with the Force to dispose of Caedus.

Her force defense is pretty good, though, she was able to block all of what Caedus was throwing.

Even if she was temporarily knocked away, Caedus can definitely hold til she rejoins. And actually taking her out with force would take a lot of effort even for Sidious, an amount of effort I don't think he can spare with Caedus around.

And Caedus isn't as powerful as Sidious, so that comparison isn't valid.

They can beat all but DE.

I got AIDS when somone said Caedus > DE Palpatine, tbh.

Originally posted by Deronn_solo
I got AIDS when somone said Caedus > DE Palpatine, tbh.

There are actually 1-2 people who place Caedus there in these forums. Its quite depressing.

Wait who the **** is the second person?

Who is the one you know?

Board Walker

Also, I don't see Sheev beating them in sabers.