Count Dooku/Darth Malgus vs. Rebels Vader/ROTJ Luke

Round 1: Lightsabers only
Round 2: All out fight

Battle takes place on neutral ground

Team 1.

Team 1 in both scenarios.

Team 1. Luke is what bring this team down. Neither one can beat vader on thier own but combined the two win.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
Neither one can beat vader on thier own

Dooku has at least a chance against Vader.

Vader's TK is a level above Dooku's, but Dooku's the more mobile and faster fencer.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Dooku has at least a chance against Vader.

Vader's TK is a level above Dooku's, but Dooku's the more mobile and faster fencer.

I completely agree because no duelist is going to simply take down dooku and not suffer or work for it.

Let me ask you a question do you think vader could simply ragdoll dooku or do you think for a time dooku could resist it with his own TK barrier.

Team 2 has a chance at sabers only, but they can't take an all-fight fight.

Luke is the weakest link. Team 1 with moderate diff.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
I completely agree because no duelist is going to simply take down dooku and not suffer or work for it.

Let me ask you a question do you think vader could simply ragdoll dooku or do you think for a time dooku could resist it with his own TK barrier.

I don't think Vader can instant TK Dooku, the way Sidious can to Maul/Opress.

But I do think Dooku has to obviously avoid getting blasted by Vader's Beastly TK, and best way is to stay all over him in Sabers.

Vader is definitely above either of his opponents, though both could give him a fight. Not sure how ROTJ Luke ranks or compares.

ROTJ Luke has no defense against lightning and has virtually no TK feats. Malgus or Dooku would have a field day with him. Vader then dies horribly against his predecessor and his clone.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Team 2 has a chance at sabers only, but they can't take an all-fight fight.

Do you think ANH Canon Vader has comparable skill feats to Malgus or Dooku?

Well both Luke and Vader are Djem So practitioners who are relatively even in strength and Vader has bent durasteel with his cybernetics enhancing his already formidable strength. Either one would be a good match for Dooku. The unknown variable here is Malgus. I lack knowledge on this character so I can't really determine an outcome. If Malgus is stronger then Luke or Vader team 1 should win, if he's weaker team 2.