Revan/Darth Malak vs. Darth Bane/Darth Malgus (Ligtsabers only)

Started by DarthAnt663 pages

Zannah vs Revan/Malak duo, Neph? Sabers only.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Well if you look at the age gap between Bastila and Revan...

19 is legal. Barely legal, but still legal.

Kinda funny since he must have pounded her on the Ebon Hawk since she was pregnant a couple months after.

Just picture Juhani and Mission just standing there awkwardly hearing them moan LMFAO.

In true BioWare fashion, most of the others probably all just sit there and try to ignore it, but never fully succeed. Then they awkwardly bring it up later when they're losing an argument.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Kinda funny since he must have pounded her on the Ebon Hawk since she was pregnant a couple months after.

Just picture Juhani and Mission just standing there awkwardly hearing them moan LMFAO.

Well according to HK they used to regularly go bang in the cargo hold. I imagine they locked the blast doors which muffled most of the sounds...

Interesting fight tbh.

Still anyone wanna hear my description of Revan lightsaber fighting style???

Yes! Go ahead.

up

Team 1. Revan>=<Bane, Malak>Malgus

Bane is a serious weakness. Malgus could take down one before he falls though

Imo, Malgus is the weak link, lol.

Revan>Malgus~Bane>Malak or Revan>Malgus>Bane~Malak

Originally posted by Ursumeles
Imo, Malgus is the weak link, lol.

Lack of feats?

Revan and Malak in a good fight.

Originally posted by TenebrousWay
Lack of feats? [/B]

More or less, yeah. I have the FE in the miidle of Tier 8, but not exactly on the Level of Bane, Revan or Malak, tbh.

Bane and Malgus.

Originally posted by Ursumeles
More or less, yeah. I have the FE in the miidle of Tier 8, but not exactly on the Level of Bane, Revan or Malak, tbh.

Yeah, he's far less documented than the others. I position him higher (low 9) mainly due to Sidious' accolades, especially considering that Sidious tracked both Malgus and Bane texts and highlighted the former capabilities as warrior.

The fact that Sidious put Malgus on the same ballpark* as Talzin, Bane, Sorzus Syn and Plagueis solely due to his capacity as a warrior is something I put great value in.

But I understand your more skeptical approach. By feats alone, we don't have much to compare.

*Obivously, not generally in power but in importance to the Sith tradition, too.

Originally posted by TenebrousWay
Yeah, he's far less documented than the others. I position him higher (low 9) mainly due to Sidious' accolades, especially considering that Sidious tracked both Malgus and Bane texts and highlighted the former capabilities as warrior.

The fact that Sidious put Malgus on the same ballpark* as Talzin, Bane, Sorzus Syn and Plagueis solely due to his capacity as a warrior is something I put great value in.

But I understand your more skeptical approach. By feats alone, we don't have much to compare.

*Obivously, not generally in power but in importance to the Sith tradition, too.


Yeah. I still see him superior to the SoR Protags in the Force, and just under them in sabers. Also, I wouldn't put too much, in Palpatkne having him in the same ballpark as Plagueis-he put Bane there too, and Bane is canonically far weaker than Plagueis. Still a good quote, nonethless.

Bane has the highest and best detailed saber feats of the four, and his showings put him at a level above the other three. The rain feat, Zannah's perception of where he is in DoE, and his combat throughout the trilogy put him at the top of this foursome easily. Given what Malgus, who again has rather detailed descriptions of what he can manage, did in both the novel and SWTOR he and Bane easily take the day in a saber duel.

Malak is poo relatively speaking here, and Revan's strengths without a doubt lie almost entirely in the realm of pure Force manipulation, not saber combat.

👆