Darth Vader Vs Darth Sidious Lightsaber Duel

Started by Lord Stark5 pages
Originally posted by The Merchant
I'm A OK with Vader being a better duelist.

So you're okay with ANH Kenobi and ROTJ Luke being Sidious-tier or above swordsmen? 😆

I guess that settles that Kenobi>>>>Maul then.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
That's fine, you do realize the same list has Vader above Sidious right? No of course you don't because You're a Troll.

Vader > Windu confirmed. Love that 😄

Wow, Lucas and Filoni really cut you deep inside. 😂

You are the one who just goes off the opinions of others not the facts. So by your own logic Maul is greater than Dooku.

I think for myself based off the facts and Windu is definitely above Darth Vader.

Originally posted by Lord Stark
So you're okay with ANH Kenobi and ROTJ Luke being Sidious-tier or above swordsmen? 😆

I guess that settles that Kenobi>>>>Maul then.

Yes.

Originally posted by quanchi112
You are the one who just goes off the opinions of others not the facts. So by your own logic Maul is greater than Dooku.

I think for myself based off the facts and Windu is definitely above Darth Vader.

Going by showings TPM maul had trouble with Qui Gon. Dooku could easily take down qui Gon, as Dooku was able to take on the combined might of Anakin and Obi wan, and survive a bout with Yoda, without being disarmed or anything. A stronger version of Maul had trouble with a broken Kenobi. Dooku has greater feats, and greater accolades from characters of high calbiers.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
Going by showings TPM maul had trouble with Qui Gon. Dooku could easily take down qui Gon, as Dooku was able to take on the combined might of Anakin and Obi wan, and survive a bout with Yoda, without being disarmed or anything. A stronger version of Maul had trouble with a broken Kenobi. Dooku has greater feats, and greater accolades from characters of high calbiers.
Abc logic. Maul bested Qui. Anakin bested Dooku but lost to Kenobi so it doesn't add up. Don't be ridiculous.

Dooku was slower, less aggressive, and considerably older.

This is all off topic.

Originally posted by The Merchant
Yes.

😂 Wait, you're serious? 😆

Originally posted by quanchi112
You are the one who just goes off the opinions of others not the facts. So by your own logic Maul is greater than Dooku.

I think for myself based off the facts and Windu is definitely above Darth Vader.

😂

In other words:

I was ready to jump on this "evidence" which said Maul > Dooku, but now that you've told me it says Vader is better than Sidious, and Ventress is better than Kylo Ren, I better quickly backtrack

Originally posted by Lord Stark
😂 Wait, you're serious? 😆

You're just mad Ahsoka can defeat Sidious in pure sabers now.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
😂

In other words:

I was ready to jump on this "evidence" which said Maul > Dooku, but now that you've told me it says Vader is better than Sidious, and Ventress is better than Kylo Ren, I better quickly backtrack

I am simply showing you are hypocritical in your own opinion. You cherry pick certain opinions and certain facts while ignoring the others. I don't. Maul>>Dooku.

Originally posted by Lord Stark
😂 Wait, you're serious? 😆

It's almost as if Luke required no more training for his tasks...

Originally posted by quanchi112
I am simply showing you are hypocritical in your own opinion. You cherry pick certain opinions and certain facts while ignoring the others. I don't. Maul>>Dooku.

Nice attempt at back tracking. But won't work on me TROLL.

You came in here, heard about the so called evidence and quickly jumped on it shouting "I TOLD YOU SO I TOLD YOU MAUL>DOOKU"

Now you're going off on a completely random rant about people's opinions (nothing to do with the topic at hand) in a lame attempt to cover your backtracking.

You are Lame.

And I own you As Per Ususl.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Nice attempt at back tracking. But won't work on me TROLL.

You came in here, heard about the so called evidence and quickly jumped on it shouting "I TOLD YOU SO I TOLD YOU MAUL>DOOKU"

Now you're going off on a completely random rant about people's opinions (nothing to do with the topic at hand) in a lame attempt to cover your backtracking.

You are Lame.

And I own you As Per Ususl.

According to the sources who determine your opinion they agreed with me making this delicious irony.

By your own criteria you're wrong. This isn't my criteria this is yours. Soak it up and enjoy Disney riding my coat tails. 💃

Originally posted by Lord Stark
So you're okay with ANH Kenobi and ROTJ Luke being Sidious-tier or above swordsmen? 😆

I guess that settles that Kenobi>>>>Maul then.

Or maybe Sidious just got really shit in his old age. 😮‍💨

Can somebody show a scan of top lightsaber duelists?

Originally posted by quanchi112
According to the sources who determine your opinion they agreed with me making this delicious irony.

By your own criteria you're wrong. This isn't my criteria this is yours. Soak it up and enjoy Disney riding my coat tails. 💃

It's not my criteria at all. I've rated combatants according top5 lists.

I go according to canon facts. You Hate Disney Star Wars 😂

Funny though how you were ready to jump on this list until I told you about Vader being on top 😆

Originally posted by ILS
Or maybe Sidious just got really shit in his old age. 😮‍💨

I have no idea why you think it's referring to OT Sidious when these 3 PT era combatants in the list.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
It's not my criteria at all. I've rated combatants according top5 lists.

I go according to canon facts. You Hate Disney Star Wars 😂

Funny though how you were ready to jump on this list until I told you about Vader being on top 😆

You have always gone by what others have told you but you ignore this proving you are a hypocrite.

I am all about facts you are about biased interpretations. Mace wins the fight and you say Sidious was about to win. You disrespect Disney canon all the time. I think for myself so am soaking up the delicious irony with you distancing yourself from it.

Originally posted by quanchi112
You have always gone by what others have told you but you ignore this proving you are a hypocrite.

And by others you mean Lucas or Lucasfilm? 😂

Originally posted by quanchi112
I am all about facts you are about biased interpretations. Mace wins the fight and you say Sidious was about to win. You disrespect Disney canon all the time. I think for myself so am soaking up the delicious irony with you distancing yourself from it.

You hate Disney Star Wars 😂

Originally posted by Darth Thor
And by others you mean Lucas or Lucasfilm? 😂

You hate Disney Star Wars 😂

A writer's opinion on a matchup he didn't write is just his opinion. Star Wars isn't handled by one guy anymore. Lucas' opinion matters over scenes and facts he's written i.e. his interpretation. If Lucas said now Kanan beats Ventress that's just his opinion which isn't a fact.

Love Disney Star Wars. They hired Abrams. An article came post my proclamations of other fans mimicking my faith in this film. Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.

🙂

Originally posted by quanchi112
A writer's opinion on a matchup he didn't write is just his opinion. Star Wars isn't handled by one guy anymore. Lucas' opinion matters over scenes and facts he's written i.e. his interpretation. If Lucas said now Kanan beats Ventress that's just his opinion which isn't a fact.

Love Disney Star Wars. They hired Abrams. An article came post my proclamations of other fans mimicking my faith in this film. Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.

🙂

Exactly Lucas doesn't run the show anymore. It's Disney Star Wars sources that count now. But you keep clinging to Lucas's words in Verses forums. You have no respect for Disney SW like me 😂