ROTJ Luke & ROTS Obi-wan vs. Darth Maul & Savage Opress

1. Sabers
2. Force
3. All out

Hmmm...I think Luke would be able to smart enough to avoid Savage's power attacks and find an opening.

This comes down to Maul vs Kenobi
I assume you mean SoD Maul?

Hmmm... If Luke can finish off Savage in time to help Kenobi then I see this as a Jedi win.

A SoD Maul is significantly more powerful than clone wars Maul and we all saw Kenobi get an @$$ whoopin when they did meet.

Unless Kenobi pulls off what he did on Florum, which isn't likely, I'm going to have to give it to team Maul.

Yes SoD maul

Originally posted by Kurk

A SoD Maul is significantly more powerful than clone wars Maul

Proof he's signifcantly more powerful?

SOD Maul is likely Prime Maul, but don't forget ROTS Kenobi is also Prime Kenobi.

Originally posted by Kurk
and we all saw Kenobi get an @$$ whoopin when they did meet.

When was that? I'd hardly call "Revenge" an ass whooping. Especially when Kenobi was winning until he got distracted helping Ventress.

Originally posted by Rebel95
Yes SoD maul

Environment?

Originally posted by Darth Thor
When was that? I'd hardly call "Revenge" an ass whooping. Especially when Kenobi was winning until he got distracted helping Ventress.

And he was just recovering from a concussion.

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
And he was just recovering from a concussion.

That part I don't give too much thought to, considering how Kanan gave his best performance against the Inquisitor after just having been tortured for days. And also considering Maul faced his own disadvantages in that fight- Like this being his first proper Saber fight in 10+years.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
That part I don't give too much thought to, considering how Kanan gave his best performance against the Inquisitor after just having been tortured for days. And also considering Maul faced his own disadvantages in that fight- Like this being his first proper Saber fight in 10+years.

Yeah there's that too I guess. Maul isn't exactly on his A game; new ostrich legs, blinded by burning hatred.

In the end it really depends on the scenario to put it into either Kenobi's or Maul's favor.

Originally posted by Kurk
In the end it really depends on the scenario to put it into either Kenobi's or Maul's favor.

👆

Kenobi fights better in tight environments.

Luke will kill Savage.

Obi Wan can't take Maul, but neither can Maul take Kenobi out quickly. Kenobi can hold for a damn long time. And typically does, even if he's losing. As such, Luke vs. Savage finishes first, and Maul can't beat both of them.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Environment?

Originally posted by Rebel95
Tatooine desert

Hmm That might benefit the brothers then, as they can make us of their mean TK waves.

I favour Kenobi and Luke in a pure lightsaber duel in a great fight. The brother's power edge in all out is too profound to ignore for me, so they take that round without a doubt and logically a Force-only as well.

👆