I did a breakdown of this recently on another forum (Herochat) with scans of every fight they've had etc, so if anyone hasn't seen their various fights, they can all be seen in chronological order here:
http://herochat.com/index.php?topic=6820.msg134364#msg134364
***Apologies for linking to another board (I'm not sure what the rules are on that front). I was trying to repost all those scans here, but it can be a serious pain in the arse to do posts like that on this forum. First the character count and then the limit on image numbers made it more trouble than it was worth to transfer the post over to here.***
Back on topic - based on their shared history, about the best you could make a serious argument for is 6/10 either way. They are peers, give or take a bit. Either can beat the other depending on how the circumstances stack up on any given day.
Cheers.
Originally posted by namorsubby
Cap slim majority....he has a shield.
The shield has historically been a non-factor against Daredevil. In fact, Matt has casually disarmed Cap no fewer than five times by my count. In three of those cases, Matt was the one who ended up using the shield as a weapon.
Cheers.