Originally posted by Surtur
I think though for some people the bottom line comes down to: Obama told people they could keep their plans and doctors.Is this true? If not then did Obama lie or was he just mistaken?
Yes, it's true, and the answer is, it's hard to say since he made the promise before the ACA's final form.
But to go into it further on what happened, you could keep your plans, unless the 'plan' turned out to be a piece-of-crap not-really-plan that'd screw you over if you ever got really sick or hurt and leave you millions in debt. You can keep your doctor unless they were only attached to such a plan (which is not overly common but does happen) or the doctor decided to pull out for whatever reason. The vast majority of cases, plans and doctors were kept, speaking in generality, most people were able to keep both.
Also, even if it's a lie? It's a lie upward.
It's like saying, "You can keep your boat!" and then turning around and when the plan hits, replacing any boat with holes in it or that is otherwise about to sink. What was actually done is better than what was said.
Personally, I'm relatively fine with people doing better than what's promised, even if it's not what was originally said.
"Hey, this isn't my worn-out guitar!"
"Haha, you now have a vintage les paul!"
"This isn't candy corn!"
"Snickers for you this halloween!"
"This isn't Star Trek V!"
"Nope, Wrath of Khan!"
Inaccurate information give through either error or deceit? Yes. This horrible thing we should be hating President of the United States Barack Obama for? Noooot so much.
Note how when people bring it up, they like to avoid going into the practical effect of what happened as a result, and there's a definite reason for that. "Someone replaced the crappy bits," is not the greatest attack in the world.