Vader/Malgus vs. Kyle Katarn/Plo Koon/ROTS Kenobi

Fight takes place on neutral ground

*All out fight

No one?

Team 1

Vader

I'd say the Jedi team. Any one of them could change either Sith by themselves.

^^LAL, no.

Honestly, Vader can solo if he fights like he logically should, rather than his personal enjoyment.

FE Malgus? Sith stomp. Return!Malgus? Should be a nice battle.

Hmm. I don't even acknowledge FE Malgus, so if it's Deceived Malgus...

Vader can defeat anybody on team 2 without any debate. He can put up a great fight against any duo from team 2, and loses in a great combat against a duo including Obi-Wan.

Malgus can defeat anybody sans Obi-Wan, and is defeated in a great fight against any possible duo.

Honestly a toss up.

What grieves me, is a fact that Vader was never shown as someone who is capable to subdue a really strong enemy (f.e. Kenobi) by his TK. Excluding perhaps TFU, which exaggerated characters skills somehow.

Originally posted by JKBart
Hmm. I don't even acknowledge FE Malgus,

Originally posted by McP
What grieves me, is a fact that Vader was never shown as someone who is capable to subdue a really strong enemy (f.e. Kenobi) by his TK. Excluding perhaps TFU, which exaggerated characters skills somehow.

He dominated Jax Pavan and Ferus Olin long before his prime, both of whom are powerful Jedi, and he is arguably far above Dooku and Maul, who did dominate Kenobi, therefore Vader can as well. Also, this idea that TFU is exaggerated, therefore shouldn't be acknowledged makes no sense when we'll soon get Vader Down, which is basically TFU/OCW 2.0, and which will be as canon as the movies. Also by this logic you should disregard Kotor 2 and Tor as well, yet people only seem to have problems when PT/OT characters get insane feats.

Originally posted by Nargaroth
He dominated Jax Pavan and Ferus Olin long before his prime

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
That's like Uthar Wynn level shit, rofl

Feats for Uthar? And I was only responding to McP saying Vader never dominated powerful Jedi, which is false.

Vader isn't soloing, but the Sith team wins.

If he fights like he should, then yes he can.

Has Vader ever fought like he should though?

mmm

Not really, but I meant in a theoretical sense.

He never fights that way, lol.

Theoretically, you phucking strawberry.

These entire fights are theoretical, lmfao.

And I don't really have a reason to believe Vader will "fight as he should", so yeah, he isn't soloing.

Team 1 solidly