Tbh I'd go Mace right now. Could be convinced otherwise, or solidified in my stance though.
REB
Rebel95Senior Member
I think it depends how the fight goes. Vader definitely has the force edge, but if he doesn't use that to his advantage I could see him losing. His limited mobility would be a huge disadvantage in a saber fight against Mace.
DT
Darth ThorSenior Member
Honestly can go either way.
These are the 2 ultimate dark side and light side combatants (after Yoda and Palpatine of course).
NEW
NewGuy01perpetual
Darth Plagueis and Luke Skywalker. ❌
CAR
carthagePLEASE PROTECT ME STONES
Vader wins
GOD
godemperortrumpRestricted
Mace wins with ease
DAR
DarthAnt66DarthAnt66
Mace spanks him.
XSU
XSUPREMEXSKILLZThe Immortal Emperor
Originally posted by NewGuy01 Darth Plagueis and Luke Skywalker. ❌
Why is Snoke the ultimate darksider, iyo?
DEA
deathslashPyromaniacal Humanitarian
Mace takes sabers and Vader takes force. It's a coin flip on who wins an all out fight.
DT
Darth ThorSenior Member
Originally posted by NewGuy01 Darth Plagueis and Luke Skywalker. ❌
Luke's above the mortal tier system.
Meh to Plagueis.
ROC
Rockydonovangfreedom fighter
Originally posted by deathslash Mace takes sabers and Vader takes force. It's a coin flip on who wins an all out fight.
Mace's Vapaad likely tips things in his favor
REL
relentless1Dark Overlord of KMC
Vader is stronger and depending on what time period Vader is he's definitely better with the Force and with saber combat in general; what he may lack in finesse his cybernetics more than make up for in strength
QUA
quanchi112Disney
Windu smokes him.
SLA
slayneRevanite
Vader, assuming he's in his prime.
Mace wins if we're going by the rules specified in the OP, though.
ROC
Rockydonovangfreedom fighter
Originally posted by relentless1 Vader is stronger and depending on what time period Vader is he's definitely better with the Force and with saber combat in general; what he may lack in finesse his cybernetics more than make up for in strength
There's noting that places Vader on par, let alone superior to Mace as a duelist.
QUA
quanchi112Disney
Originally posted by Rebel95 I think it depends how the fight goes. Vader definitely has the force edge, but if he doesn't use that to his advantage I could see him losing. His limited mobility would be a huge disadvantage in a saber fight against Mace.
Did the force edge for Yoda beat Dooku ?
REB
Rebel95Senior Member
Originally posted by quanchi112 Did the force edge for Yoda beat Dooku ?
He certainly wasn't losing. And Yoda doesn't use the force offensively like Vader does anyways so that's kinda a poor comparison
DEA
deathslashPyromaniacal Humanitarian
Originally posted by Rebel95 He certainly wasn't losing. And Yoda doesn't use the force offensively like Vader does anyways so that's kinda a poor comparison
👆 and when he did use it offensively against Dooku's superior (palpatine), he ragdolled him.
DT
Darth ThorSenior Member
Originally posted by quanchi112 Did the force edge for Yoda beat Dooku ?
The "Force edge" made Dooku Palpatine's b**** from across the galaxy.
Also made Ventress a non factor to Yoda, and Maul a joke to Sidious.
ROC
Rockydonovangfreedom fighter
Legends goes to Mace due to Vapaad and Vader not being as high as a duelist
Canon could go either way as Mace no longer has the super conductive loop to turn things in his favor and in canon even a significantly pre-prime Vader could be argued to be a Dooku level duelist.