2015 Game of the Year

Fallout 4, Super Mario maker and Undertale is what I'm trying to choose between

Originally posted by Jesus McBurger
Fallout 4, Super Mario maker and Undertale is what I'm trying to choose between

Let me help you there, don't choose Fallout 4 👆

Originally posted by Bentley
Let me help you there, don't choose Fallout 4 👆

Originally posted by FinalAnswer
By who?

Certainly not me, given that it is inferior to both the games that preceded it and New Vegas.

Everyone without taste, sure.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Everyone without taste, sure.

Fallout 3 bored me to tears.

Needless to say, FO4 certainly isn't my game of the year.

If Telltale Walking Dead is a GOTY, you better believe I'm giving Devastation my nod. (And I liked both the original and sequel, but they aren't really even interactive novels.. Choices don't change much, at all.)

The campaign may be short, but the challenges more then make up for it. Taking on the Seekers or Optimus and Megatron at the same time?

Better yet, beating down Bumblebee with a big assed hammer, and then dino chomping him like a pitbull at a cock fight? 😂

Originally posted by Jmanghan
Metacritic puts at a 91. Which means it has Universal Acclaim.

Lots of people recognize that it's a great game. Which it is.

But one of the best or THE best of all time? Haha no.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
Metacritic puts at a 91. Which means it has Universal Acclaim.

Undertale has a Metacritic score of 94, which is higher then the rest of the games listed on this poll 🙂

I haven't actually played Undertale, and from what I observed, it didn't have anything resembling combat.

I still don't see the appeal about Undertale. I do think I overreacted about it a bit, as Indie games can be as good as Triple A games.

Still makes me uncomfortable that a 2D Indie game might be GOTY Material.

It does have combat.

And there's nothing wrong with a game being 2D, people still wack themselves off to Chrono Trigger and the Mother series as being GOAT.

And it may be indie, but Toby was working on it for like over 3 years, it's not like there wasn't a lot of work that went into it.

Bloodborne.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
I haven't actually played Undertale, and from what I observed, it didn't have anything resembling combat.

Lol.

Undertale is probably the hardest game on the list except Bloodborne imo. I just watched a video of a streamer trying 7 hours to beat a boss (condensed of course). Yes, theres bosses. Yes, theres combat. Yes, the combat is good.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
I haven't actually played Undertale, and from what I observed, it didn't have anything resembling combat.

I still don't see the appeal about Undertale. I do think I overreacted about it a bit, as Indie games can be as good as Triple A games.

Still makes me uncomfortable that a 2D Indie game might be GOTY Material.

Originally posted by Astner
Bloodborne.

I'm on board

Originally posted by Nephthys
Lol.

Undertale is probably the hardest game on the list except Bloodborne imo. I just watched a video of a streamer trying 7 hours to beat a boss (condensed of course). Yes, theres bosses. Yes, theres combat. Yes, the combat is good.

Only scum bags fight that boss though.

Originally posted by FinalAnswer
Only scum bags fight that boss though.

Originally posted by Jesus McBurger
Why not fallout 4? It's a great game and lived up to its hype

I did not say it was a bad game, it's a fitting sequel.

Ahhh