No way, Luke was fully awake and aware of his surroundings, he saw the Wampa and recognized his situation. Then he had to close his eyes and focus for several seconds to even wiggle the lightsaber let alone get it before the Wampa got to him, meanwhile Rey took that same saber away from an accomplished Force user in Kylo Ren after a Force struggle for it.
Rey > ESB Luke.
You and I disagree then, which is fine, though keep in mind Luke got Stronger as ESB went on. Do you think Rey would do as well against Vader than Luke did on Cloud City? Personally, I dont think so. This is a close match, but to me ESB Luke (especially after his Yoda training) is a bit too much for Rey (who clearly had some Force Epiphany at the end, which at this point is a bit unexplained).
Luke was hanging upside down and was severely injured when he was calling to his Saber which seemed stuck in the snow.
Yes the scene was about his training as well, how he should close his eyes and connect to the Force, but it definitely wasn't the same situation as just casually calling his Saber to him under normal circumstances.
Any healed version of ESB Luke wins.
Have to go with Luke on this one, I don't think Rey could have done this well against Vader.